StriderShinryu said:
Chrono Trigger is a JRPG from the SNES era that, to my knowledge, is the first major title to have a New Game Plus mode. The difference, as you've stated, is that CT isn't a loot fest ARPG. CT is, at it's core, a JRPG that has 12ish endings, some of which require you to have finished the game at least once to access. Thus, yeah, there really is no real comparison between NG+ in CT and what is basically NG+ in D3. NG+ in CT lets you play through the same game in different ways, actually coming to sometimes radically different endings. NG+ in D3 means you play the whole game over again with exactly the same experience just hoping you get good enough loot drops to keep you moving forward.
Now now, let's be REALLY honest.
CT's multiple endings were not at all from divergent paths, but simply due to when in the narrative you decided to defeat the end boss. That's all. Otherwise, the second playthrough's story is EXACTLY the same, and all the combat is simply a formality because difficulty doesn't change to suit NG+.
D3, on the other hand, actually DOES ratchet up the difficulty, so that the actual process of killing does change. On top of this, your character, unlike CT, will actually acquire new abilities, thus keeping the gameplay varied over time.
Fundamentally, Chrono Trigger's NG+ gimmick is that you get to start powerful enough to take Lavos on and see what-if endings but the gameplay itself is simply an unnecessary timesink. Diablo 3 actually adds depth to the gameplay as you get to higher levels of play.
You're right, they aren't at all different.
Lunar Templar said:
poiumty said:
Boudica said:
Sounds pretty silly.
Will something this shallow and pointless really keep people from leaving or win back the legion of disappointed leavers? Probably not.
No it's not, and yes it will. People have been asking for this for a long time. People aren't leaving because D3 is a
bad game, but because of a lack of progression once you hit max level.
or .... a lack of anything to do after finishing the story (no, the extra diff don't count, i mean real content not doing the old stuff again), the nerfs that are just shallow means of forcing people to the AH, cause god forbid some one beat a boss with less then prefect gear -.-
Infinite regression--the game has to be finite. If the game's narrative length is long enough, it's long enough. If people want to play on harder modes, why not?
Besides, the game's only been out for a couple months, isn't the cry for MORE CONTENT a bit premature?
And it's no different in this respect than Diablo 2. Sure, D2 had an expansion pack, but that wasn't right away, was it? Of course not.
The bottom line is... it's an option for people who like that style of play. Some people DO, you know. For those who don't... don't do it. If you just want to play d3 for the main story, and play many alts, go right ahead. No one has any right to tell you to stop having fun the way you like.
And if you happen to be the sort that likes putting in work to get the perfect set of gear, and that's where you get a sense of accomplishment... who is ANYONE to call them stupid for that?
The ONLY fail here are jerks who try to tell others that they're stupid for enjoying a playstyle that the jerk doesn't want to understand. All the cries of 'Skinner Box' and not a single bit of empathy or attempt to understand why these people might actually have a legitimate reason for enjoying it.
For some, they like to see how fast they can accomplish a task. They started off moving slowly and cautiously but eventually they get to a point where they're steamrolling, and they want to see how fast they CAN steamroll. This is -legitimate fun.- Others want to see how high they can get their stats as an exercise in rediculousness. It's okay to do this at the D&D table but when they do it in Diablo it's suddenly 'stupid'?! Bah! Some people just like the feeling of accomplishment when they manage to put together what they see as a finely tuned machine. Hot-rod affectionados in real life don't get flak for this, but do it in a video game and suddenly you're 'an addict?'
Bah. It's disrespectfully judgemental bullshit and nothing more than that.