You agree with the OPs sentiments that people should stand up for themselves... but at the same time the OP is promoting a draconian, and highly flawed, approach to bullies. Bullies aren't just school yard ruffians who like to punch stuff. There is an entire spectrum of bullying and only a fraction of it is physical abuse. Social platforms like Facebook have also drastically altered the way bullying works. People aren't just being punched up or jeered, they are being tormented.Luna said:lmao. the first thing I do in my initial post is criticize the strawmen arguments in response to OP. and then the person that challenges me uses a strawman argument. 'hur dur, he thinks it must be the victim's fault because he thinks standing up to bullies can sometimes be the right thing to do'Ragsnstitches said:Care to elaborate on how the OP is right? Is it the victim blaming? Or the inferred cowardice of putting pressure on the victim rather then confronting the bully? I mentioned this earlier already, but if your strong enough to stand up for yourself, what's stopping you from standing up for others?Luna said:The OP is right. lol at the strawman arguments in response to OP, 'no one deserves to be bullied'. Nice try.
what's stopping me from standing up from others is that sometimes they're in... oh i don't know... a different location to myself.Apart from having no backbone of course.
The irony of the OPs position is that his "logic" equates to bullying anyway. He assumes that the act of bullying stems from a fault in the victim and is merely exploited by the bully. That the victim has an inherent flaw and it's their responsibility to sort out. He forgets that bullying can in fact induce this flaw. A bully can whittle down a persons will until they become incapable of standing up for themselves, which in turn, emboldens the bullies actions.
The irony of your position is that you criticize OP for bullying and challenge him, making you the bully.
^I seriously think calling you a bully is ridiculous, but is equally ridiculous as your assertion that he is a bully. Anyway...
What's more he forgets that bullies are RARELY individual threats, but instead a group of peers who derive pleasure from tormenting an individual. These are bullies that initiate and incessantly pursue aggressive/oppressive actions towards the victim. But we also have another sort, the ones who sit on the sides and let it happen, feeling some smug satisfaction or sense of superiority over the victim.
You, and the OP, are the latter.
Boy, you don't know a thing about me. So don't pretend you do. I've probably done things that you wouldn't have the courage to.
don't call the OP a fucking dick, please. I don't appreciate this bullying behavior.This logic makes him (quite blatantly) unsympathetic to victims of bullying and ultimately belittles the struggles of said victims. Given the right situation, I wouldn't be surprised if he would harass someone or physically intimidate them himself, whether that person is deserving of it or not. You see, he has already convinced himself that the bully is not the problem, but the person with no courage to rebel against the bully is. So he would think all he's doing is giving the poor sod a taste of real life, rather then being completely objective about it and seeing that he's just being a fucking dick.
What you said is basically a strawman argument anyway so I'll quickly say that you're a manipulative over assuming individual who believes what he wants to believe.
As I said earlier. If you actively promote opposing bullies, then why the fuck don't you act as you preach? Are bullies only a bully if they are bullying you? No. Then why not stand up to bullies on principle?
Oh yeah, the aforementioned absence of a backbone might be why.
who says I don't? You might as well go stand in a field and scare off crows because this man of straw is overwhelming.
It can be inferred from the OPs language and his logic that he thinks we are all cut from the same cloth, and because he could handle one type bullying on his own (I doubt it btw, I bet he had support in some way or form), he figures everyone else is just being wimpy and the media/politicians are being overly PC or sensationalist (a grain of truth to that, but the OP is actively devaluing the strife of victims, based off of less then virtuous mediums).
He also assumes that the only avenue of counter bullying is confrontation. It might work on a school yard, but as the OP establishes outside of school and in the real world, the playing field is entirely different. "Bullies" in those environments aren't the lugheaded bruisers we see on TV and the means in which they degrade people are far more vicious and clinical. Even if someone does physically attack you in the real world, chances are they won't be using their fists.
I'm not challenging the OP. The questions I threw out were clearly rhetorical. ALso, I mucked up some phrasing. I didn't mean to say you and the OP ARE bullies, but that you are another sort of person who adds to the problem. I did say, that given the right situation, your (OPs specifically, but you have already agreed wholeheartedly) macho superiority complex could result in you targeting and tormenting someone who may or may not deserve it... since you already agree that people should stand up for themselves, and that confrontation is the only solution, it's not your problem if someone can't handle teasing or physical intimidation.
I'm pretty sure the OP can handle a few harsh words and a angered opinion. He is after all a completely awesome and self made man. Though I must commend you for standing up for him. That's all I'm trying to preach here. So, from this point on I will cease the verbal jabs.
Just to clarify, I was intentionally trying to goad the OP, and you, into properly explaining your logic, or at least open you to an alternative opinion. The OP seems to hold himself to a standard that others should follow and I wanted to break that narrow logic. You merely nodded and agreed. I'm honestly not sure which I think is worse. Logical fallacies have a use in some cases.
You still haven't explained your view on this, instead fell on discrediting me and my argument without submitting your own. All I have to go on is my own belief as neither you or the OP have offered anything substantial to work off of. There are others on here who have agreed with the OPs sentiments, but elaborated on it. Those opinions I agree with to an extent. The OP, and by extension you, have not elaborated on anything and assume your logic is obvious and/or universal.
I'm not going to have a dick measuring contest with you. You probably could have done things more courageous then me, but that doesn't make your perspective more valid, especially if you hold it as a standard to judge others.
I hate refocusing a subject onto my own problems, because it feels like I'm fishing for sympathy. Forewarning: I don't want your sympathy (not that I expect it) nor do I want to "move" you with my own troubles:
I have been bullied (no shit right), but it wasn't the conventional bullying you and the OP assume is the only type of bullying. This was something I couldn't confront. Heck I wasn't even aware of it... it was just routine for me, a daily dose of "reality" as the OP would probably put it. I was degraded, belittled, tormented and manipulated daily for 20~ years. The bully had complete control over me and even had my respect and love.
The bully was my Mom. The realisation never hit me. I had massive self-esteem issues for most of my life. Despite having good friends, being good in school, having no one in particular who actively hated me and being a talented artist, I had no confidence in myself. I was into sports, but gradually faded out, gained weight and became reclusive during my teens. All this stemmed from daily verbal abuse I grew up with. In my mums eyes, I was a fat, lazy, selfish, ungrateful, and ultimately just a "typical" man. Yes, my mum was a man hater. She projected her insecurities onto me, and vented her own strife at me, because I didn't know any better.
The reality of my situation only came to light when I flunked a course I had a lot of interest and investment in twice and sought counselling. During this time realisations were springing up from everyone in the family. My Dad left her shortly afterwards leaving mom to wallow in her spite. She took that and fuelled her anger. I was suddenly a homewrecker and bully. Yup. I was suddenly a bully. At this point I was aware of my situation and I reacted, be blasting her with all my anger and frustration. Now my mum doesn't make a peep in my direction unless I initiate a conversation.
The sad thing is, I don't hate her, and I don't believe she hates me. I feel guilt now for confronting her as I feel like I may have been the hair that broke the camels back. Dad had left her, but I was stuck in the house trying to keep some semblance of peace. My mom became volatile and belligerent, sometimes charging into my room and shouting at me because she thinks I was talking behind her back with dad. She tried to drive a wedge between my sis and I and our dad by claiming he cheated on her (dad left after she cornered me and started calling me a bully, at which point I had a breakdown). As a result of counselling and support from friends and family I managed to build up some courage and finally stood up to her. I just wish I didn't have to confront her at all.
I couldn't have stood up to her on my own, since it didn't even register that she was a problem. I just assumed that I was the useless sack of flesh she saw in me.
If your curious as to why my Dad didn't stand up to her. Well, he didn't see the issue either. In fact, he was also bullied and tormented, and like myself just assumed mum was right about him. He would call her out when she used harsh language on me or tell her to back off when I started having frequent freakouts.
The bully was my Mom. The realisation never hit me. I had massive self-esteem issues for most of my life. Despite having good friends, being good in school, having no one in particular who actively hated me and being a talented artist, I had no confidence in myself. I was into sports, but gradually faded out, gained weight and became reclusive during my teens. All this stemmed from daily verbal abuse I grew up with. In my mums eyes, I was a fat, lazy, selfish, ungrateful, and ultimately just a "typical" man. Yes, my mum was a man hater. She projected her insecurities onto me, and vented her own strife at me, because I didn't know any better.
The reality of my situation only came to light when I flunked a course I had a lot of interest and investment in twice and sought counselling. During this time realisations were springing up from everyone in the family. My Dad left her shortly afterwards leaving mom to wallow in her spite. She took that and fuelled her anger. I was suddenly a homewrecker and bully. Yup. I was suddenly a bully. At this point I was aware of my situation and I reacted, be blasting her with all my anger and frustration. Now my mum doesn't make a peep in my direction unless I initiate a conversation.
The sad thing is, I don't hate her, and I don't believe she hates me. I feel guilt now for confronting her as I feel like I may have been the hair that broke the camels back. Dad had left her, but I was stuck in the house trying to keep some semblance of peace. My mom became volatile and belligerent, sometimes charging into my room and shouting at me because she thinks I was talking behind her back with dad. She tried to drive a wedge between my sis and I and our dad by claiming he cheated on her (dad left after she cornered me and started calling me a bully, at which point I had a breakdown). As a result of counselling and support from friends and family I managed to build up some courage and finally stood up to her. I just wish I didn't have to confront her at all.
I couldn't have stood up to her on my own, since it didn't even register that she was a problem. I just assumed that I was the useless sack of flesh she saw in me.
If your curious as to why my Dad didn't stand up to her. Well, he didn't see the issue either. In fact, he was also bullied and tormented, and like myself just assumed mum was right about him. He would call her out when she used harsh language on me or tell her to back off when I started having frequent freakouts.
Despite all this, despite having grown significantly in the last few years in terms of confidence and esteem, I sitll struggle with bouts of depression and crippling social anxiety. What really screws things up is that I refuse to just ignore mom and have been actively trying to patch things up with her.
But what would have happened if my life was a little different? What if my Dad was also abusive, if I didn't have friends and I didn't see a counsellor. What would I think of myself if I didn't find my passion for drawing and art? I sank very far even with the care and consideration of others. If they were absent how low could I have gone?
The point is, my case of bullying wasn't overt and obvious like a schoolyard knucklehead. If I confronted her (Which I did at certain points in my life) she would blast me as being a bully and feel vindicated in degrading me even more. No one would tell her off, since she was just being a strict mother (on the surface). It was long and protracted expeirence, sinking deep into my psyche and subverting my thoughts so that they would work against me at every aspect of my life. To the outside world our family was fine, I was just a wimpy kid with no spine, while in reality I was pushed to the floor and being kept there by an oppressor.
I only broke free as a result of the support others gave me. Left to my own devices I feel like I would have either sunk into a deep depression or perhaps even snap.
People should not be left to stand on their own. Yes it should be a trait we strive for, but we exist as a social creature for a reason. The strong should cover the weak. People who can take a hit should take the hits of people who can't. People with power to intervene should do so for people with no power of their own. That's all I'm trying to say.