People may argue that HL2 was original and started a trend and that the reason it may seem bland by modern standards is to do with other games copying it but I disagree.
I bought it on release and it bored me then, still does now. The puzzles didn't strike me as clever or amusing so much as they seemed contrived and existing soley to show off the physics engine.
That said, I think Halo 2 & 3 are overrated too.
On the other hand, the original Half Life and Halo were a joy to play and still are.
Edit: If anyone wants to accuse me of being some kind of Zero Punctuation apologist, the review I wrote several years ago on release of HL2 is a matter of public record and I'd be happy to direct you to it.
I bought it on release and it bored me then, still does now. The puzzles didn't strike me as clever or amusing so much as they seemed contrived and existing soley to show off the physics engine.
That said, I think Halo 2 & 3 are overrated too.
On the other hand, the original Half Life and Halo were a joy to play and still are.
Edit: If anyone wants to accuse me of being some kind of Zero Punctuation apologist, the review I wrote several years ago on release of HL2 is a matter of public record and I'd be happy to direct you to it.