I like Halo as much as the next Xbox fanboy, but there is no way in hell a Halo MMo would ever, EVER come even close to competing with WoW. The Halo fanbase is made-up mostly of shooter fans, which is about as far away from an MMO player as it gets.
Quite true, almost every MMO ive ever heard of has been said that it can "Stand up" to WoW, or even "kill it" but the problem is, WoW just has so much of a head start, that with all the patches, its been refined to near-perfection. Ive tried out some MMO's, and Now ive been settled into WoW for years, always as a fallback when a new MMO disapoints meBaron Khaine said:*rolls eyes*
Its easy to say it would have beat WoW it when it never came out. Every MMO has been called a WoW Killer recently, and they all failed. This one would have been no different.