I don't know, Cliffy. I actually liked Gears for what it was, and I know that the original tried to be kind of scary, but I don't think you could really pull off Resident Evil.
...though, I'm not sure if I wouldn't want to see you try...I mean, in terms of pulling off ridiculous premises, Gears kind of ranks up there. After all, it's not everyday someone pulls off a grim-dark apocolypse with the undergrond monarch of the mole people.
In all honesty, if he feels that he could pull it off, I'd like to see him try. After all, it is outside of his comfort zone to do a survival horror game. As long as he kept the chest high walls to a minimum, showed restraint with the weapons, and kept QTEs out, it might turn out alright. Maybe?