Ok, I bought it. Knee-jerk reaction from my extremely limited playtime: I hate the basic combat.
I wasn't planning on trying it today, but after the 3 hour install time, I decided just to peek a bit. I got to the first combat section in the tutorial, and it just feels awful. Maybe I've been spoiled by the weight and intention of FROM games' combat, and I've not played anything else like this in forever, but this just feels cheap and janky by comparison. I literally only played for 5 minutes, so this isn't a final indictment, just a shock to the system that this style of game [for me] has a high bar set by
Dark Souls/Elden Ring that I didn't realize was there.
I bought it, so I'm obviously going to play it more to get a more robust feel for it. Hopefully it either get's better or my standards lower to meet it where it excels. Who knows, maybe the basic combat mechanics isn't where it shines, and I need to get into all the menus and submenus to wring the joy out of it. Maybe all the stuff you can do that isn't combat is fun and worth my while. I hear you can put armor on cats; that's a thing, I guess?