The People's Joker (2022)
Strap in, we're getting conceptual. So, The People's Joker is an abstract mixed media autobiographical comedy about the life and career of transgender comedian Vera Drew framed by a weirdly specific parody of the Batman series and its various cinematic adaptations.
TPJ follows Vera Drew's fictionalized self as a closeted trans kid in... Smallville, Kansas, put on prescription medicine by her hysterical mother before moving to Gotham City, where comedy has been outlawed by presidential candidate Bruce Wayne, which is how she ends up opening an anti comedy club with her friend The Penguin and embracing her true self as Joker the Harlequin and dating trans man Mister J as they try to stay out of the repressive reach of Bruce Wayne and his alter ego Batman. All done in a style that blends different types of animation with live action. Like I said. Conceptual.
This took about 2 years to get an official release, because, as you might figure, it's not exactly copyright friendly. And, I mean, it's cool that it exists. When I was reviewing Barbie and Everything, Everywhere all at Once I was complaining about the way these big, mainstream american comedy movies were appropriating the tropes of early 00's style experimental humour for its twee, sentimental and at their core deeply conventional productions. TPJ is very decidedly not that. If nothing else, it does feel genuinely experimental and transgressive, where pioneers like Tim Heidecker and Bob Odenkirk, not to mention oddball puppeteer David Liebe-Hart, mainstay on the Tim and Eric show, actually show up.
Honestly, though, I couldn't really get into it. If you have to, I think you can boil down TPJ to three underlying themes: The experience of being a trans person, the experience of being a comedian and the experience of being really, really into Batman. I can't particularly relate to any of these experiences and only occasionally did it's efforts to squeeze humor out of them connect with me. When Roger Ebert, patron saint of all modern film critics, reviewed Tim and Eric's Billion Dollar Movie, the cinematic debut of experimental comedians Tim Heidecker and Eric Wareheim, back in 2012, he famously wrote:
"I feel I've failed Tim and Eric. They've gathered a cult following by doing comedy sketches that were deliberately bad, and now they've made a movie that is more of the same for 92 minutes, and it must have taken them a great deal of work to maintain their low standard. By not finding even one moment of "Tim and Eric's Billion Dollar Movie" to be slightly funny, have I let down the side?
There is a scene in this film where a character is defecated on by several people at the same time, and I dunno … I didn't enjoy it."
A sentiment that I never shared because, as far as I am concerned, Tim and Eric are hilarious and Billion Dollar Movie was hilarious. People's Joker left me wondering if I'm in Ebert's place now, because while I don't think anyone ever gets defecated on in it... I dunno... I didn't enjoy it. I certainly respected it a good deal. It's mixed media approach makes it feel a bit like the unruly, camp sibling to Hundreds of Beavers earlier this year, it certainly doesn't pull any punches in committing to its visual style. Hell, it starts off with a dedication to Joel Schumacher and if that isn't a statement, I don't know what is.
Long story short, I think People's Joker is pretty cool conceptually, but it's not for me. It left me feeling vaguely the way Flying Lotus's bold, but borderline unwatchable, gross-out comedy Kuso did, although it goes down a lot easier than that. It's a unique little piece of film making and I'm excited to see how Vera Drew is going to follow it up but this is made for a cult audience that I'm just not part of. Clearly it's an extremely personal project and I'm happy movies like these get made but honestly? Didn't do much for me.