Rebel Moon: Bigger, Longer and Uncut (2024)
The long awaited (...at least by me) uncut release of Zack Snyder's space fantasy epic Rebel Moon. I saw, and greatly enjoyed, the first movie when it came out and decided to hold out on the second one so I can watch the uncut releases back to back.
I expressed some of my misgivings with the release method of these movies back when I wrote a review on the first one, and perhaps it is redundant to reiterate them now, but hear me out. Film critic Armond White, previously one of the few defenders of Snyder's work among the critical establishment, stated, that in resigning himself to making two versions of each of his movies, Snyder had "become his own Joss Whedon". Referencing, of course, the director Warner Brothers hired to cut Justice League into something almost no one involved wanted anything to do with. While that is a cruel thing to say, I can't in good conscience say it's necessarily wrong. Snyder seems to some extent have resigned himself to compromise. What I think White doesn't want to concede, though, is that that compromise is more than most other directors ever get.
So, here's the long version of Rebel Moon. The real version of Rebel Moon. The first movie extended by about one hour and 20 minutes, the second one by a bit under an hour. Will it win over anyone who hated the short versions? Hell no! It's, in essence, more of what they didn't like in the first place. Characters get more screentime, plot points and world building are expanded upon and god knows, there's a lot more violence. And some more sex, but mostly more violence. It's probably the goriest semi-mainstream action movie since 2021's The Suicide Squad, easily. It's funniest change is probably that a sequence set in what, in the censored version, was described to be a bar turns out to have been set in a brothel all along.
I have summarized the plot in my review for the short version, but for those who are new here: Sophia Boutella plays Kora. She's a fugitive former elite soldier of a totalitarian galactic empire. She's hiding out in a farming village. The farming village is threatened by the imperial army. Kora travels the galaxy to recruit its greatest warriors to protect the village. They face off in a great battle. Something something Seven Samurai, something something Star Wars.
Now that we got the whole thing I finally feel ready to articulate my thoughts on it. And let's be honest, you all know what they are: I binged all of it, I adored it, I want more of it. I know what the general critical response to these movies is, I can't relate to it at all. This feels like some displaced artefact from the mid 00's, a time when blockbuster film making was saturated with lavish, indulgent, adventurous and earnest to a fault genre pieces that, in retrospect, everyone took for granted. This is coming from exactly the same place movies like Lord of the Rings, Pirates of the Carribean or... well, 300 came from. Unapologetically genre. Unapologetically pulp. Unapologetically unwilling to not take themselves 100% seriously.
And here's the thing. I don't even disagree with the detractors, Rebel Moon asks you to take a lot of extremely goofy worldbuilding and plotting completely seriously. A villain reads a dead man's memory from his leaking brain matter after he bashed his head in. The chief of a farming village tells his people to "fuck for the harvest" at a village festival. A woman assembles the greatest warriors of the entire galaxy to protect a tiny village. Imperial space ships are powered by people shoveling the dead remains of their enemies into a furnace like in a coal powered train. There are characters with names like "Darrian Bloodaxe" and "Atticus Noble" and "Nemesis". The extended cut of the first movie adds an entire subplot about a robot having a religious awakening while strolling through wheat fields and delivering Terrence Malick monologues and, I swear, it's the most kino shit you're ever gonna see.
Believe it or not, Rebel Moon is Snyder's most spiritual film. All those mildly awkward musings about "faith" and "myth" that Justice League suddenly found itself tremendously interested in after putting aside Batman v Superman's more political preoccupations are now the backbone of Rebel Moon. I have previously mentioned that there is a flashback in the movie where employs straight up fairy tale imagery but so much backstory is relayed by characters telling their stories to each other. There is an extended sequence in the second movie where, I swear to god, all the warriors Kora recruited sit at a table and individually recite how they were wronged by the Imperium with each of them getting their own little flashback sequence. Hell, also in the second movie is this wonderful montage, probably one of the best things Snyder ever directed, where all the people Kora assembled, farmers and soldiers and rebels and even an orphaned prince, work on the fields harvesting grain in harmonious unity with the people of the village, now all equal as farmers and labourers, that feels like something from a communist propaganda movie. It damn near brought a tear to my eyes, man.
Listen, I know people don't like these movies, I know they're somewhere at around 15% on Rotten Tomatoes or something. I'm not here to tell them they're wrong or that they need to fix their heart. I've been a hobby film critic for a while and if there's anything I know about this most lowly form of writing it's that its sole product are overly personal, elitist expressions of subjective opinion, devoid of purpose or interest to practically anyone but their author. But straight up, I'm all in on this series and I really hope that Netflix is as supportive of it as Snyder claims they are because, I'm gonna be honest, seeing another series of his abandoned before it's finished would break my greasy heart.