Star Wars (A New Hope)
The Empire Strikes Back
Return of the Jedi
And so my Star Wars nostalgia and catch-up era ends with a rewatch of the original trilogy (I made sure to find the true original versions not the FrankenLucas bullcrap).
To recap this watchathon consisted of:
- Prequel trilogy (1st rewatch since they originally came out)
- Clone Wars cartoons, abridged, first/only watch
- Rebels cartoon, first/only watch
- Obi Wan Kenobi, first/only
- Andor, rewatch
- The first half of the Solo movie (fell asleep halfway through, didn't care enough to finish)
- Rogue One, 2nd rewatch
(I have watched the Mandalorian, Book of Boba Fett, and the sequel trilogy, but that was when they came out, before this current marathon)
Of course I know the original trilogy by heart so all I have to say about it now is how remarkably well it holds up. I cannot fairly judge how much nostalgia or familiarity plays into it- it may be like declaring that my right arm is the best arm there could be or something, I mean what else would I know. This is the gold standard action sci-fi entertainment that all others have had to contend with for my affection.
Watching the modern stuff like Andor/Rogue One right before felt a lot less jarring than I had feared. Credit must go to the production staff and crew of the modern stuff that adhered so closely to the original look and feel I suppose.
Even getting a fun little detail like: at the end of Rogue One, Vader and stormtroopers invade a rebel ship in clear homage to the beginning of the original SW, but in R1 Vader leads the troop and reeks havoc. In the original, he just lets his goons do all the work and he strolls in, which is even more intimidating. Imagine seeing that dude for the first time ever like that!
And at the risk of even more nostalgia glowing- the sheer force of personalities of Harrison Ford and Carrie Fisher, the enthusiasm of Mark Hammill- none of the many hundreds of other Star Wars comes even close to that. I think the reason Andor works is that they don't even try, they go another way, with intensity and politics and themes, which is cool 'cause it's different.
Han Solo is just so f'n cool. He's the coolest! His smug smile at everything, charging at a gaggle of stormtroopers by himself, laughing off Luke Skywalkers jealous crush pouting about Leia.
As for the other stuff, well Rebels was mostly really solid, though some of the plot stuff at the end was silly but that's ok and I hate its cliffhanger-ish ending (no I'm not going to watch Ahsoka, I just don't care about anything that happens after Darth Vader and the Emperor die, the story is over as far as I'm concerned). But I liked the characters well enough. But honestly no cartoon will ever be as good as movie with for-real humans anyway for me. And I already posted about Clone Wars, which I'm glad I watched for the sake of Anakin and Ahsoka.
It was a trip to see Thrawn! The Heir to the Empire trilogy is the only Star Wars books I ever read, they were such a big deal back in the day. I was in my prime sci-fi / fantasy reading days and devouring all of that kind of crap so reading a compelling SW villain that wasn't an evil jedi and about Han and Leia's budding marriage was awessome at the time. But with the whole Disney / Legends / "canon" thing I just never imagined they'd dredge up Thrawn or any of that stuff. Goes to show what I know. I didn't particularly find him interesting in Rebels unfortunately, all he did was act smug and declare all his failures to be victories, but whatever.
What Rebels did handle real well was the two jedi characters as individuals and their relationships. And in the last two seasons I was pleasantly surprised by how invested I got in Sabine and the mandalorians, given how little I cared about the mandelorians by the second season of their titular show.
But, you know- none of that extra crap adds anything of value to the original trilogy. I was wondering if it would.
Even something like when Obi Wan' let Vader kill him- there was this whole flashback and theme in the Obi Wan show where OW shows Anakin that Anakin's fault is that he wants to win too badly and prove he's better all the time. But Alec Guinness already tells us that in the moment in the movie "if you strike me down I shall become more powerful..." blah blah. So does the prequel add anything? eh.... just another version of the same thing, really.
Certainly the biggest thing is Andor/Rogue1 making us appreciate the insane sacrifices various characters had to make to get those plans to Leia, and even just forming a "Rebel Alliance." But that's also why Andor works as its own story.
How does old Star Wars look to the young people? To me it looks modern, not like an "old" movie. Yeah you can see some of the budget constraints in the original, but my god does Empire still look freaking epic to my old eyes. I think the only thing that stands out as looking "old fashioned' are the droids. C3PO is like something out of Buck Rogers, when people though "robot" meant clanky awkward thing. Just a few years later James Cameron taught us that a robot can look indistinguishable from a person.
I was wondering if the gap in my mind between the quality of the original films and the prequels/sequels/spinoffs were as big as I remembered. No it wasn't- it was even more so.
Here's my fantasy alternate reality of the Star Wars franchise we would get after the original trilogy.
Star Wars Episode 1: The Clone Wars, in which promising young jedi and his slightly older compatriot Obi Wan get sucked into this stupid civil war
Star Wars Episode 2: The Phantom Menace, in which the true nature of the conflict is revealed and we see into the machinations of the impending Sith and Anakin's descent into darkness
Star Wars Episode 3: The Sunset of the Jedi, which is basically just a better version of the episode 3 we got.
Importantly, George Lucas would provide the story outline and some consultation on world building and overall design then f*** off to go swim in his giant pool of gold coins while others write, cast, and direct.
Star Wars: Rebels type TV show, but with real people (my bias of live action over animated). But like the animated, more action and "positive," geared towards younger audiences.
Rogue One as-is and Andor but with 3 or 4 seasons to give what we got in the second season more time to breathe.
And that's it. No sequels. Because the evil emperor dies and the heroes win. Jub-jub.