I thought Rebirth was better than Dominion, if only because it remembered this franchise is still about, you know, dinos.
Well, no, but I got this for my mum, who wants to own all the films in the franchise on DVD, despite not actually liking them all, due to being a completionist.Were you expecting anything more?
You know you can tell her not everything needs to be collected, and it's best to ignore bad sequals and pretend they don't exist. I have some bad movies, but i'm not looking to collect every single bad sequel. I make my own stopping point, and move on. You can let her know that I told you this personally, if you wish. It's her choice either way.Well, no, but I got this for my mum, who wants to own all the films in the franchise on DVD, despite not actually liking them all, due to being a completionist.
Ok, iirc, it's a combination of three reasons. Firstly, it was Leto's growing popularity in the Landsraad, and Shaddam is just a plain jealous and petty ruler. Secondly, because the Atreides were training a specialized military that rivaled the Sardaukar in skill, and Shaddam feared that if left alone, this could threaten his monopoly on power. And lastly, Shaddam was being manipulated by the Bene Gesserit into taking out the Atreides because Jessica bore Leto a son when they wanted a girl, and this threatened their Kwisatz Haderach breeding program.Also, and maybe someone who's read the series can enlighten me on a point. As I understand it Emperor Shaddam IV had the Atreides ended because of Leto's growing popularity and wishes to knock on the head perhaps any designs on the Imperial Throne of Leto's. But - at least as depicted in Part Two - Shaddam has a daughter, Irulan, but mentions no sons. He even says in one scene that Irulan would make a formidible Empress. Now if that succession isn't possible, why didn't he just ask Leto to betrothe Paul to Irulan? Like I get power tends to patralineal in these situations but there's worse fates for a great house than to join with another one who's star is rising to at least keep their skin in the game.
You know in retrospect that all seems rather obvious and I should have parsed it out.Ok, iirc, it's a combination of three reasons. Firstly, it was Leto's growing popularity in the Landsraad, and Shaddam is just a plain jealous and petty ruler. Secondly, because the Atreides were training a specialized military that rivaled the Sardaukar in skill, and Shaddam feared that if left alone, this could threaten his monopoly on power. And lastly, Shaddam was being manipulated by the Bene Gesserit into taking out the Atreides because Jessica bore Leto a son when they wanted a girl, and this threatened their Kwisatz Haderach breeding program.
If the movies have a flaw, it's that it's easy to miss a lot of the politics and motivations because they are in some cases compacted into basically a single line.You know in retrospect that all seems rather obvious and I should have parsed it out.
Well I mean, at that point being a hypocrite is kind of small potatoes to the litany of bullshit he's been party to.If the movies have a flaw, it's that it's easy to miss a lot of the politics and motivations because they are in some cases compacted into basically a single line.
Tho since we're talking about it
Reason 1 and 2 make Shaddam's explanation in part 2 for why he betrayed Leto, for being a weak man ruled by the heart, a serious display of hypocrisy.


