Star Trek Discovery Season 5
A ten hour long, mediocre goose chase with no pay off at the end.
And by ten hours I mean ten episodes, not in-universe ten hours. A waste of time.
I finally watched the finale last night (wife was traveling for work and we watch the show together).
My big Trek hot take is that Discovery is the best Trek since Deep Space Nine.
The show was a mess, often confused and all over the place due primarily to behind-the-scenes turmoil. But it was also, at its best, the only Trek show or movie that had any heart, any ambition, and anything new. The shows that get positive attention like Strange New Worlds and Picard season 3 are lame nostalgia bait. The fact that I'm so split from the vocal Trek fan base just tells me what I felt in my heart since the days of Voyager- it was really time to move on. No franchise needs to go on forever.
The final season of Discovery was a bit disappointing plot wise where it's a video game quest basically. But there were individual episodes and scenes that worked. They managed to do one thing well I've never seen another show do well- introduce a new character in the final season and make me care about them. I called this phenomenon the Ezri Dax Problem- DS9 is rightfully beloved but its last season is
rough and a big part of that was introducing a new, more annoying Dax that I couldn't be arsed about. Discovery gives us an ornery second in command that is a nice counterpoint to the all-about-the-feels vibe of the other characters.
And it's the reaction to that last point that bothers me most about some of the hatred for Discovery. Yes, the characters talk about their feelings and work together and are friends. This is where we have to remember that Trek works when its utopian and positive. One of my problems with the first season of Discovery is one of my problems with the Abrams movies- sometimes they try to go grimdark cynical because that is the trend and, like- let literally every other sci-fi show do that.
Season 3 has them going to the far future and bringing classic Trek positivity to a broken world and that was the most Star Trek idea the whole franchise had in decades and everybody hated it lol... no let's see the same references, spin-offs, nostalgia b.s. a million times? Guh, no thanks!
I do with the finale ended with the wedding and the scene on the beach. I read an article explaining that they didn't even know it was gonna be the last season and so tacked on that flash-forward epilogue. Typical of the kind of production b.s. that prevented the show from reaching its full potential. Either way I didn't need to see them be old and have a kid and make references I had to research on the internet to other sub-standard Trek things I didn't care about.
What did work was Burnam, Book and Mol figuring out their personal baggage THROUGH a crazy science/tech thing while the spaceship crew performs fantastical feats of derring-do. That is where Trek shines Discovery worked when it just did that.
Well, whatever- I hear they're planning to re-re-boot the movies...