Doctor Who
- Thread starter Natemans
- Start date
Recommended Videos
I think its what hes given to work with - Moffat really did not make best use of the actor OR character imo. There are moments but thats it :-/pookie101 said:
Peter Capaldi could have been a great Doctor but it always felt to me that they were continuing to write for Matt Smith.
It was same same in Smith's first series, a lot of the episodes felt as if they were written for the Tennant incarnation of the Doctor.
However while Smith eventually found his own voice as the Doctor, Capaldi has never been given that opportunity, he's never felt like a distinct incarnation.
It was same same in Smith's first series, a lot of the episodes felt as if they were written for the Tennant incarnation of the Doctor.
However while Smith eventually found his own voice as the Doctor, Capaldi has never been given that opportunity, he's never felt like a distinct incarnation.
Doctor Who - SE10 EP01 Thoughts:
The pictures on the desk?
The picture from the box?
The 'Coming Soon' bit at the end
The pictures on the desk?
Loved seeing River and Susan. So sad.
Clearly The Doctor knew her mom. I almost wonder if she's related to a previous companion.
The 'Coming Soon' bit at the end
OG Cybermen? YES!
Return of female Master, aka: Missy? YES!
Return of John Simm's Master? HOLY FUCKING FUCK THAT FUCKING PREVIEW HOLY FUCKING FUCK WITH A SIDE OF OMG DA FUK?!?!?!?!?!?!
Return of female Master, aka: Missy? YES!
Return of John Simm's Master? HOLY FUCKING FUCK THAT FUCKING PREVIEW HOLY FUCKING FUCK WITH A SIDE OF OMG DA FUK?!?!?!?!?!?!
Tanis said:
Holy shitballs, Simm is BACK!? As you can probably tell I'm a massive Simm fan. Simm as the Master made theworld 7.3 billion times better with one stunt ... I fangirlgasmed.
So what did everyone think of it?
Personally I kinda thought it was decent. Only complaints are that the villain defeat left me a bit underwhelmed and the Daleks plus Movellans were wasted as just plot fodder. I like Pearl Mackie, but some of her dialogue was a bit too....I don't what the word is. No, not awful or bad. Just something off or weird.
But despite that, I think this was a pretty decent start and hope the rest of the season turns out good.
Personally I kinda thought it was decent. Only complaints are that the villain defeat left me a bit underwhelmed and the Daleks plus Movellans were wasted as just plot fodder. I like Pearl Mackie, but some of her dialogue was a bit too....I don't what the word is. No, not awful or bad. Just something off or weird.
But despite that, I think this was a pretty decent start and hope the rest of the season turns out good.
Tanis said:
I think the implication was the Doctor popped back in time and took pictures of her mom as a christmas present for Bill
Pretty nice opening episode. Seems abit more subdued, which is a good thing as the series tends to veer into obnoxious territory alot. Kinda sucks The new companion seems nice.
No to the second.
The new girl is ok looking, but she doesn't look like a model or anything.Elijin said:
No to the second.
I liked it pretty well, even though it was glaringly obvious it was designed as an entry point for new viewers. I'm not sure yet if I'll like the new companion, but it's been one episode. I do want to enjoy Capaldi's last season, I like his Doctor.
My one big issue, well, question maybe, it's not a huge deal...
My one big issue, well, question maybe, it's not a huge deal...
If the alien oil spill can cross time and space as fast as the TARDIS, then what the hell do the aliens who left it need with a star ship in the first place? Just lather yourself up in motor oil and travel effortlessly anywhere and anytime you want. I mean, that is some oddly advanced tech in what was presumably a run of the mill space ship.
The biggest questions I was left with in this first episode of the season/series were when the hell did The Doctor become a university professor? and who the hell did he make that promise to? and when and why did he make it?
You can even see the start of his regeneration in the "this season" teaser at the end of the episode.gigastar said:
On that topic, they really give away way to much in the next week clip.
That was really annoying last season, and i hoped that they wouldn't do that anymore(but alas)
As for bill, well i just don't know yet.
The trailers for this season made her uit as not really that bright but makes up for that with her mouth.
The episode did take that away at least a bit.
Although, i do think that her talk then think habit will annoy me time to time.
But by going to classes during her brake she does show room to grow.
But i do think she will even be harder to really get used to than Donna was.
The first episode was...okay I guess. Can't say I like the new companion much yet. She's supposed to be smart, but runs her mouth like she's incredibly stupid. Maybe that'll change. It feels like they're trying to go outside of the norm for the sake of it. (talking about how the companion reacts to the tardis, her going 'doctor what?', the Doctor and Nardole going 'about time' when she finally says 'it's bigger on the inside' and such.)
I'm glad that this is Moffat's last season. He's made some very good single episodes, but I don't like how he tries to push this big overarching important plot into every season. Or maybe it's because those overarching haven't been that good in my opinion. I dunno...
Either way, I'm going to have to wait and see how this season will turn out. Maybe I'll grow to like Bill after a while, just like how I started to like Clara after a while. (And then Moffat ruined it with her at the end. Let's hope that doesn't happen.)
I'm glad that this is Moffat's last season. He's made some very good single episodes, but I don't like how he tries to push this big overarching important plot into every season. Or maybe it's because those overarching haven't been that good in my opinion. I dunno...
Either way, I'm going to have to wait and see how this season will turn out. Maybe I'll grow to like Bill after a while, just like how I started to like Clara after a while. (And then Moffat ruined it with her at the end. Let's hope that doesn't happen.)
I agree. I don't know if skirting the norm was what they were going for, but what they did was make her look like a moron. There were some legitimately good character moments with her like when she was looking at the box of pictures and when she had to release the water doppelganger (I know it wasn't really water, shut up), however overall I still found her kinda annoying.sanquin said: