Does Portal even need a sequel?

[Enzeru92]

Yes portal 1 doesn't need a sequel but the fans sure as hell do want a sequel of the awesomenage that is Portal.

And come on Portal 2 looks bad ass from the gels and the lasers it all looks really cool

 

[Wrds]

Didn't Gabe say that Portal 2 is the greatest game Valve has made to date?

Pretty sure he said that in some interview.

 

[Wolfram23]

I think it'll be good. IMO, Portal was like a really fun and well made tech demo. But it was lacking in some respects. It seems to me that Portal 2 is going to be the "real game"

 

[LightOfDarkness]

Didn't Gabe say that Portal 2 is the greatest game Valve has made to date?

Pretty sure he said that in some interview.

He said that Portal 2 for PS3 will be the best console version.

I don't know why he didn't just say it would be better than the 360 version.

Unless the Wii would be getting it's own version.

 

[Lord Honk]

It doesn't NEED one, but if one gets made anyway, why not be happy about itOHMYGOD IT'S GONNA BE SO AWESOME!!! xD

All seriousness aside, I love portal's gameplay and story, They'll have a hard time fething either up too bad from what the trailers show

Then again, that'll only encourage them to try and refute my thesis

 

[TPiddy]

Most of the gameplay demos look fantastic.... it looks like the puzzles will be harder, there will be more humour and more all-around fun.... Hells yes.

 

[Nautical Honors Society]

If you are looking at the story line of Portal than no if it didn't have a sequel then it would go down as one of the greatest games of all time and possibly the greatest puzzle game ever created.

But if you are looking at it from a level of length and player satisfaction than yes Portal definitely needs a sequel because I am sure if you liked Portal you will love the longer enhanced version of it.

 

[Gaming King]

I need to experience Portal, but I only have a Wii and PS3, so heck yes I need a PS3 Portal.

 

[Enigmers]

I think it works on its own, but would also be great as a series/trilogy/whatever Valve want to do with it.

 

[Carnagath]

Portal 2 looks like an actual sequel, not a rushed rehash like L4D2. The other actual sequel that Valve made was Half Life 2. You see where I'm going with this. I am 100% confident that they can produce gameplay that will make Portal 1 feel like a child's drawing. However, Portal is much more than just the gameplay, there are many little elements that clicked in a marvelous way and made the first game such an absolute joy: The art design, the (black) humour, the clever writing, the ambience, the "nerdy" atmosphere, that god damned song in the end... Can Valve also hit all those key points for the sequel and improve them ever more? That remains to be seen...

 

[jamesworkshop]

It needs a sequel because everyone wants a sequel other than that I don't hold Portal as sacred its fun but thats about it


Portal 2 already looks to be hands down better than the first

repulsion gel and aerial faith plates =

Wheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

 

[The Diabolical Biz]

I think it was necessary, but I don't wanna get too hyped about it - I generally prepare for the worst in games, and games quite often, sadly, fall far short of expectations...

 

[SextusMaximus]

It didn't need one but it's getting one... I'm not complaining.

 

[Layzor]

I would like to play some more, stop being all artsy fartsy about it.

 

[-Samurai-]

I'm not really looking at as a sequel, but more of an expansion. More levels can only help the game.

In terms of story, well. There really wasn't one.

 

[Assassin Xaero]

I thought it was way to short to just have ended there... And no this isn't some L4D/L4D2 rant type thing with sequels, but Portal seemed more like a beta to me just by the length of it and about half of it seeming like tutorials... Portal 2 looks like it really builds on that and shows just how much is actually possible...

 

[Fallen-Angel Risen-Demon]

Is it needed?
No.
Will I get it?
Fuck yes.

 

[PurplePlatypus]

As far as I remember, Portal was meant as a tester, or at least it was a short game to test out a concept. It was done remarkably well and they certainly shouldn?t stop now just to quite while they're ahead. That?s kind of pessimistic, especially when they seem to have so much more to add to both the gameplay and story.

 

[lumpleston]

Did half life need a sequel?

 

[Fallen-Angel Risen-Demon]

They said somthing about JC...
So the awesome song at the end looks good. *ticks*
For humor it looks like Glados and Wheatly has got it coverd and with wheatly there be some light heart(ish) humour aswell. *tick*
My brain is dead and I can't remember what ambience means but fuck it. *tick*
I've seen the E3 demo so art design. *tick*
'Nerdy atmosphere'. *checks trousers* *tick*
Yep. All coverd.
Except the writing... But there is more characters then just you Glados and companion cube so yeah. *tick*
Good on yah valve.

Portal is much more than just the gameplay, there are many little elements that clicked in a marvelous way and made the first game such an absolute joy: The art design, the (black) humour, the clever writing, the ambience, the "nerdy" atmosphere, that god damned song in the end... Can Valve also hit all those key points for the sequel and improve them ever more? That remains to be seen...

That was for you by the way...