There's nothing lucky about it, unless you consider genetics luck. Are we a bit jealous of other primates success here? Going back to the stone age are we?TheNamlessGuy said:Heh....
Lucky shot, I say
There's nothing lucky about it, unless you consider genetics luck. Are we a bit jealous of other primates success here? Going back to the stone age are we?TheNamlessGuy said:Heh....
Lucky shot, I say
That depends on ones criteria for formulating an arbitrary review score. If purely down to the individual reviewers tastes, then there is no reason a game cannot get large numbers of "perfect" scores, though also acknowledging that reviews are purely subjective. Alternatively, if the score is based on a more "objective" checklist, then again a perfect score is entirely reasonable, where the game ticks all the boxes & leaves the decision down to the readers personal tastes. From what I understand, liking Mass Effect 2 or not will boil down to whether you like Sci-fi RPGs (& Bioware's brand of RPG in particular) or not. If you do, the perfect scores reflect the likelihood that you will be hard pressed not to like this game. If not, then the review scores are ultimately irrelevant since you wouldn't have bought it anyway.The_root_of_all_evil said:Sorry, this is actually sad. There should never be a "perfect" game.Greg Tito said:40 perfect scores from gaming publications
40 "Wow, this is damn good" is fine. Can we get back to when reviews weren't all "FAIL/WIN"? Even Yahtzee has a sliding scale of crud.
Fair enough, but having one person who actually says "I didn't like this", "I think it could have been done better" would have been good.Cousin_IT said:perfectly reasonable explanation
5 stars out of 5 is technically a perfect score. When you go to metacritic and see LOADS of places scoring something 100, that's what they gave it. 5 stars out of 5.The_root_of_all_evil said:Sorry, this is actually sad. There should never be a "perfect" game.Greg Tito said:40 perfect scores from gaming publications
40 "Wow, this is damn good" is fine. Can we get back to when reviews weren't all "FAIL/WIN"? Even Yahtzee has a sliding scale of crud.
It isn't luck for a game to sell well if one person out of 2 million dislikes it.TheNamlessGuy said:Nay not really.Lonan said:There's nothing lucky about it, unless you consider genetics luck. Are we a bit jealous of other primates success here? Going back to the stone age are we?
I just don't see the fun in the game, and I for one think it's boring as hell.
Therefore I think it was a lucky shot that they went this far.
Because the game suck
I think that it's more skill in gaming development rather then luck.TheNamlessGuy said:Heh....
Lucky shot, I say
Er, this has no mention of the number of pirated copies. So therefore there could have been 2 million in sales, but 5 million pirated copies for all we know.Dommyboy said:Yet no DRM was required either for Mass Effect 2. Proof that piracy is not the main problem that developers face, but whether the game they create is actually good.
Definetly. They have excelled in this game, no doubt!JeanLuc761 said:Glad to hear it, Bioware completely deserves all the success they're having.
There are no doubt many more "perfect" movies, games & books etc out there atm. The difference between them & Avatar (& the like) is not quality, or indeed reviewer support, but the marketing/PR department & public hyperbole surrounding them. After all, it is the PR monkeys that collect all these review scores & reviewer soundbites to dangle infront of us consumers, which is how most of us probably find out what reviewers beyond our favourite publication(s) think in the first place.The_root_of_all_evil said:Fair enough, but having one person who actually says "I didn't like this", "I think it could have been done better" would have been good.Cousin_IT said:perfectly reasonable explanation
Seriously, does N perfect scores actually mean anything anymore? We're going through a global recession and we've had a perfect film, a perfect MMO, and now two perfect games?
It's all a little silly really.
(This is not to say that ME2 isn't worthy of it, I haven't played it so I wouldn't know)
AgreedJeanLuc761 said:Glad to hear it, Bioware completely deserves all the success they're having.