The people that I know who saw it were raving about it. In a good way. but i suppose it's a matter of taste.GothmogII said:Yup, like how the original Tron was Touchstone too but the sequal's got the Disney logo glued to it.TheRealCJ said:Ah, but you have to remember: The Nightmare Before Christmas belongs to Tim Burton in name only.Aura Guardian said:Loved the special message. I've hated a lot of Tim Burton's movies expect for one. Sweeny Todd. And I've have yet to watch a Nightmare before Christmas and refuse too. Judging by your review, this is crap. Thank you moviebob
He had the vauge, basic original idea, but beyond that, he didn't write it or direct it. Despite the creepy fanboyism that exists for the movie, it's actually one of the better non-Disney* children's films out there.
*Yes, I know it's Disney NOW, but it was originally released by Touchstone, because Disney proper thought that it wasn't keeping in line with it's other children's films at the time, take what you will from that.
Edit: What am I thinking? Tron was Buena Vista, heh. Still Disney though, humm.
FrossetMareritt said:Wow, for once MovieBob doesn't know his facts. Of course it seems like a vast majority of people don't that he's wrong either.
This book is NOT based off of Alice in Wonderland, it only happens to have the same title from the same series of books. It's based off of Through the Looking-Glass. Thus one of MovieBob's rants about the Red Queen being the Queen of Hearts isn't right because in the book she IS the Red Queen. And the fact that the book is taking place on a giant chess board and there is a fight going on between the White Queen and the Red Queen in which Alice takes part in.
I didn't think the movie was 'ubertacular,' but I did find it entertaining and I think that is what truly counts.
He's always that astute and to the point in every review. If you've seen any of his other reviews you'd know this is nothing new.Resin213 said:Seems pretty spot on with the review, although the delivery seems like Bob really wants to be Yahtzee.
Just saying
Well, I just saw it last night. It was, as I recalled right then, pretty. Vapid of course, but pretty. Reminded me a lot in tone of American McGee's Alice though obviously with the violence turned down to almost nil. I don't know, I this is the only adaptation of Through the Looking Glass I've seen so I've nothing to compare it to, but, it doesn't hold up well for me.Benjeezy said:The people that I know who saw it were raving about it. In a good way. but i suppose it's a matter of taste.GothmogII said:Yup, like how the original Tron was Touchstone too but the sequal's got the Disney logo glued to it.TheRealCJ said:Ah, but you have to remember: The Nightmare Before Christmas belongs to Tim Burton in name only.Aura Guardian said:Loved the special message. I've hated a lot of Tim Burton's movies expect for one. Sweeny Todd. And I've have yet to watch a Nightmare before Christmas and refuse too. Judging by your review, this is crap. Thank you moviebob
He had the vauge, basic original idea, but beyond that, he didn't write it or direct it. Despite the creepy fanboyism that exists for the movie, it's actually one of the better non-Disney* children's films out there.
*Yes, I know it's Disney NOW, but it was originally released by Touchstone, because Disney proper thought that it wasn't keeping in line with it's other children's films at the time, take what you will from that.
Edit: What am I thinking? Tron was Buena Vista, heh. Still Disney though, humm.
Also, to Gothmog: is your avatar from what i think it's from?
The title 'Alice in Wonderland' is much more known than 'Through the looking glass'. It's pretty logical from a commercial point of view.It's also a little odd that Burton's one is called Alice in Wonderland at all since it bears little relation beyond a few scenes and references to the original book, leaning more towards as mentioned above Through the Looking Glass.
^this^LiquidGrape said:I love it when people make dogmatic assumptions.Aura Guardian said:Loved the special message. I've hated a lot of Tim Burton's movies expect for one. Sweeny Todd. And I've have yet to watch a Nightmare before Christmas and refuse too. Judging by your review, this is crap. Thank you moviebob
At any rate, the general consensus seems to imply that the action climax is unwarranted.
When I've seen it myself, I'll form my opinion.
- Sweeney Todd, by the way, was Burton's most drab and uninspired film to date.