I find it interesting at how many people base their opinions on a movie because of what a critic says. Make your own opinions, people! Don't let someone else define it for you.
Anyway, I've seen this movie....how many times, now? It's a great film that's not only artistically wonderful but also has a great cast. True, Mia was a bit bland in the beginning, but she got better as it progressed. I've not read the book or seen the other Disney version in quite some time (if at all). Bob has his opinion about it, and he's entitled to it. To say the least, it's just a movie of great fun that, however dark it may seem and the Jabberwocky fight scene being a little much for the younglings, people of all ages can enjoy it. For me, it's one of my favorite Burton films, along with Sweeney Todd and Sleepy Hollow.