ColdStorage said:
Hi MovieBob, could you stop ragging on Twilight, its flawed yes... not every single piece of literature is The Divine Comedy, if you hate anything enough you will find flaws because your looking for them.
You said yourself in the Harry Potter critique you did that any flaws pointed out would not change peoples minds over it (please correct whatever you said) and whether or not they would see it.
Aren't you technically pointing out flaws in his review, and thus making the same mistake he is? And I'm pointing out how that's flawed so that means that...*head explodes from paradox* (see what I'm trying to get at? There's no point in reviewing or commenting on anything if you believe it's about changing people's minds. It's not, it's about stating your own opinion through your own medium in anyway you see fit. Of course, you're welcome to critique that as well, just thought I'd point out the broken logic haha).
At least MovieBob offers up intelligent arguments for why it's bad, rather then just attacking it mindlessly.
In relation to the review, I'm really looking forward to Predators. Although tribal societies had been known to advance slower then ones based on agriculture, it would be fully possible for the Predators to develop quickly through a hunter lifestyle if there were certain elements within their society. For example, stationary hunters (rare, but still possible) have the advantage of using less land and resources for food production. Hunting societies often have low birth rates as well, meaning that food isn't as major a problem. However, it's still difficult to catch food, and just like how farmers developed better technologies for food production, stationary hunters could develop better technologies in order to increase the population. As the population increases, expansion and colonization is needed in order to release some of the stress on the food supply. With the way the Predators advanced, it's pretty obvious that their tribal hunter nature stems from their history rather then their need. Predators don't seem to use humans for food, and thus it could be seen as a trial in order to prove that they are an effective member of society as well as a way to gain power and respect.