Vegosiux said:
Treblaine said:
This doesn't say that humans are camels! You fallaciously add in the "stock up" term when that is not the claim, the claim is that water helps prevent dehydration. This is true and has every right to be advertised, what possible reason should scientific facts ever be withheld from the public?!?
You already need to have low hydration problems in order for water "help". If you're normally hydrated, water just passes through your system, mostly. So yes, while water helps against dehydration, it doesn't exactly prevent it. "Staying hydrated" is not about "preventing dehydration", it's about an intake of liquid to balance out the liquid you lost - not about preventing you from losing it in the first place.
No. Stop taking words out of context. The term is "help prevent dehydration"
not "prevent dehydration"
OR just "help" on dehydration.
"water helps against dehydration, it doesn't exactly prevent it."
The claim is "Helps Prevent dehydration" which it most definitely does, yet the EU forbids stating that.
it's about an intake of liquid to balance out the liquid you lost - not about preventing you from losing it in the first place.
This is where you are being very deceptive, dehydration is not a PROCESS of losing water, it is the STATE of not having enough water.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmedhealth/PMH0001977/
(1) "helps prevent dehydration" DOES NOT CLAIM to "prevent water LOSS"
(2) "helps prevent dehydration" DOES CLAIM that it "helps prevent the RESULT being a state of deficiency of water"
(3) There is NO serious claim that drinking water prevents water loss.
(4) "water prevents water loss" is an irrelevant straw man argument
(5) it is False that water only helps with dehydration ONCE you have reached a state of dehydration
(6) Consuming water Does help prevent Dehydration
You haven't got a leg to stand on. All you've ever had is twisting words and logical fallacies but how about you accept these facts and work from them instead of breaking down each work of a sentence into its most obscure meaning.