I've been a huge fan of Evangelion and still say it's one of the most culturally important works in anime, but it is always refreshing to see great comics take the piss out of it. Love all of these.
See, I think this is why I don't get the hate for it. I don't have an instant adverse reaction to "unlikable" characters, which apparently, lots of people do. I like to see them learn and change (or crash and burn), and it's very easy for me to empathize with even characters who do despicable things, if they aren't just pure evil or do shit solely because they're douches.Zero=Interrupt said:Shinji's life blows, but he reacts to that by being an unlikable spineless moron, and not by rising to the occasion like, say, Simon from Gurren Lagann (whose life sucks more, arguably, because he lives underground and has to dig tunnels with a fucking HAND DRILL).
EVA in general had a fucked up nonsensical plot that ultimately ends up going to a Gainax mindfuck ending. Some people thought it was deep, other that it was fucking idiotic. I turned off the series at ep 1 because I fucking hated Shinji. That the series went on to kill the other, more likable characters an end in a stupid wau proved me right for tuning out.
But, each to his own.
Merchandizing, and the fact that the show's director said outright that a lot of the symbolism was intentionally shallow aside, it is still clear that you just don't get it.Grey Carter said:Evangeliowned
You can (not) handle these cheap shots.
Read Full Article
This, sort of. I'm also willing to wager that a lot of the marketing of Evangelion has more to do with Bandai/King Records/Revoltech/Sega and/or who else has licensing rights to the franchise than it does with Gainax/Anno. The show is both deeper than naysayers profess it is and shallower than supporters would like to think. The original Evangelion series deconstructed Super Robot tropes by infusing them with Real Robot elements and examining the real world implications there of, while also exploring the greater implications of common anime story elements at the time. That is what Gainax does and has always done. The fact that lots of anime that came afterwards borrowed heavily, or outright copied, from Evangelion doesn't detract from the point that the series was trying to make.acosn said:Merchandizing, and the fact that the show's director said outright that a lot of the symbolism was intentionally shallow aside, it is still clear that you just don't get it.Grey Carter said:Evangeliowned
You can (not) handle these cheap shots.
Read Full Article
Evangellion is a reaction to the legions of shows that have some protagonist male who leaps out of the womb with complete agency and a perfect handle on his life and where he's going with utter immunity to any wrong doing or having anything actually bad happen to them because plot armor. Shinji's thrown into an impossible situation where he can't say no or else he's a massive asshole, and if he goes along with it he's just doing the most agonizing thing possible, and gets to do it over and over, and the people who he protects because of it will just resent the shit out of him because he didn't get everything perfect.
And the only reason he even survives half the time is completely outside of his own ability or power. In the mean time every time his robot takes a blade to the head, gets an arm ripped off, or gets decapitated, he's feeling every second of it. The character makes perfect sense, he's just not someone immediately likeable. God forbid.
No, the show isn't really that deep. Yes, you still don't get it, and that's pretty sad because the show's pretty shallow. It just has a lot to say about a lot of things.
Like who?CriticKitten said:.
Yet fans of Evangelion will insist to you that their show is ALL about its depth and how it has cultural influence. It's not the marketing that makes it bad, it's that people insist that the show above all others and how it wouldn't "stoop" to the lows of another series, yet they rush to the "well, everyone does it" defense as soon as someone points out that there's a Rei mousepad, not to mention the disturbing existence of body pillows for many of the female cast members.
Basically, it's hypocrisy. Their show resorts to all the same gimmicks as other shows and shouldn't be criticized for that, but at the same time it's also some kind of god-tier work of art that no other show can match. Can't have it both ways, kids.
I find it funny how many people claim he doesn't get it, while simultaneously not getting the fact that Grey is a satirist and is not trying to make serious points. The irony is almost too much.acosn said:Merchandizing, and the fact that the show's director said outright that a lot of the symbolism was intentionally shallow aside, it is still clear that you just don't get it.
Yes, you still don't get it, and that's pretty sad because the show's pretty shallow.
Incoherent screaming of support. I'm a fan, but I like the snarky tone of these two magnificent basturds. Critical Miss would not be the same without them.Pinkamena said:*Incoherent screaming of Evangelion fans in the distance*
Ugh BennetTheSage, literally the worst anime reviewer I can think of. He relies solely off of 'MUH NOSTALGIA' and has entry level, Adult Swim taste. Even worse than JesuOtaku and the fact that Berzerk is his favourite anime says alot about his credibility as a reviewer (I say that because Berzerk sucked donkey dick compared to the manga).LazyAza said:For anyone who thinks Evangelion to be "deep and meaningful" I recommend these reviews:
http://benthesage.com/reviews/aa/anime-abandon-neon-genesis-evangelion-death-and-rebirth/
http://benthesage.com/reviews/aa/anime-abandon-the-end-of-evangelion/
Bennet White aka Sage, pointed out everything wrong with the series and the films far better than I or anyone else ever has, and did so in a very entertaining and insightful manner.
But don't mistake me, I own both the original series, the original two films and the newer two film remakes and look forward to the third. But deep and meaningful? ahhahahahah Eva is about giant robots and awkward yet hilarious anime teenager antics and little else to me, and that's all I need to enjoy it. But man that End of Eva movie, what a mind fuck.
Hating a reviewer solely because their opinions are different to you're own, way to be original.xplosive59 said:Ugh BennetTheSage, literally the worst anime reviewer I can think of. He relies solely off of 'MUH NOSTALGIA' and has entry level, Adult Swim taste. Even worse than JesuOtaku and the fact that Berzerk is his favourite anime says alot about his credibility as a reviewer (I say that because Berzerk sucked donkey dick compared to the manga).LazyAza said:For anyone who thinks Evangelion to be "deep and meaningful" I recommend these reviews:
http://benthesage.com/reviews/aa/anime-abandon-neon-genesis-evangelion-death-and-rebirth/
http://benthesage.com/reviews/aa/anime-abandon-the-end-of-evangelion/
Bennet White aka Sage, pointed out everything wrong with the series and the films far better than I or anyone else ever has, and did so in a very entertaining and insightful manner.
But don't mistake me, I own both the original series, the original two films and the newer two film remakes and look forward to the third. But deep and meaningful? ahhahahahah Eva is about giant robots and awkward yet hilarious anime teenager antics and little else to me, and that's all I need to enjoy it. But man that End of Eva movie, what a mind fuck.