Well Im not that interested in this at this point (Fantasy games are not really my thing, and Im not the most hardcore gamer out there because of my not-thinking-at-the-worst-possible-time attitude) but Personally I think that the Modded Console versions are a factor of complacency. We all think that because of the (comparitive to PC) difficulty of Modding games is difficult that we don't implement ANY form of Anticheat, whereas on the "Glorius PC platform" we have developed many anti- cheating measures, such as database verifiers and Anti-cheat platforms.venn2011 said:^ This. Seriously.LordOfInsanity said:And how would you keep a permanently online game fair and balanced? A game like Dark Souls, where people can join another's game easily to either help or attack one another, is impractical with mods in and of itself.
You could have modder A have both the Sword of Infinity + 1 and Armor of Invulnerability thanks to modding, who joins into non-modder games and continuously attacks and kills the player. How will you keep Modders and Non-Modders separate, so Modders don't grief and ruin the experience from non-modders?
The problem with the online portion of Dark Souls is that when you're online, there is no way to prevent an invasion. There are no separate rooms or password-ed games to separate modders from non-modders. You can't prevent any hacker or cheater from joining your game. If you're online, you're online; exposed & vulnerable.
The console versions already suffer from glitchers & griefers; do we really want modders with "Sword of Infinity +1" and "Armor of Invulnerability" to join in & ruin everyone's fun? This game will die in a heartbeat.
Oh sure, play offline. But if you do, you're missing out a huge portion of the game, especially the coop. Want to do coop? Need help with a boss? Gotta connect online & risk invasion; there is no other way.
Oh sure, maybe the devs can fix it or something... but I think they moved onto next project, so if they just port it as is, then it'll be a disaster waiting to happen.
As much as I'd love to see this game on PC, I agree that it may not be a good idea.
Though people say that they don't work, but in reality its due to us PC gamers being very demanding (I mean, we willingly pay craploads and research a fuckton for our gaming systems, Learn the ins and outs of many games, fall and trip over many times, there is a lot of work that goes into it, who wouldn't be overly particular)