Games you couldn't understand the hype over?

Recommended Videos

Da Orky Man

Yeah, that's me
Apr 24, 2011
2,104
0
0
TestECull said:
Mass Effect. Every gameplay video I've watched shows me a bland cover-based shooter that swapped bullets for lasers. Whoop-de-fuckin'-do, game of the year every year. /sarcasm
Just something small that annoyed me; you don't use lasers in Mass Effect. Apart from that one particle beam in ME2, which technically isn't a laser either.
 

Atmos Duality

New member
Mar 3, 2010
8,470
0
0
Bethesda titles in general past Morrowind.
I absolutely loathe being a gamer when the Bethesda hype train comes a rollin' to cut off all other topics of gaming discussion like it's cutting off my morning commute.

I can elaborate all day as to why I feel this way, but given that the topic is just one of those sampler topics, I already know that nobody really cares. So why bother justifying an opinion? I have my reasons. I have a LOT of background-experience with Bethesda games.

This isn't an opinion brought on by one or two bad experiences; it's a long, winding trail of tears and misery in the land of "Bethesda didn't really give a fuck".

Anyway...

The Bethesda-MegaGame fanbase is the only one that I can think of who paradoxically continues to lower their standards while raising their expectations with each new game, and is the only fanbase that continues to grow under such conditions.
No other community I can think of does this; who has been so willing to pay top dollar for such buggy and increasingly shallow products.

It's come to the point where they were willing to blindly throw the highest of accolades at these games WELL IN ADVANCE OF THEIR RELEASE DATES. Given that trend, I'm rightly confused as to how it keeps happening, and how it keeps getting hyped to the heavens.
 

onegirlgaming

New member
Apr 7, 2012
31
0
0
For me it has to be Journey; maybe I'm just a soulless husk of a person but this game just didn't stir anything in me above a mild admiration for the concept.
 

Smeggs

New member
Oct 21, 2008
1,251
0
0
Kahunaburger said:
Fable, Skyrim, and Kingdoms of Amalur. Just... why?
This is pretty much it.

Any other games that I felt were crap or mediocre weren't really hyped.
 

Letitha

New member
Feb 28, 2009
126
0
0
Skyrim - pretty enough, nice enough gameplay but too glitchy and I didn't feel driven enough to actually complete the storyline (I didn't really do anything past the starting quests until I'd finished the Dark Brotherhood line...and still haven't finished the main storyline because I can't be bothered).

Prototype - Looked awful and I had no idea why I was supposed to care about any of the characters, least of all Alex Mercer. The only positive was that the movement system was fluid ;)

Anything with terrible graphics - I don't know why, it just really annoys me.
 

Don Savik

New member
Aug 27, 2011
913
0
0
Djinn8 said:
In b4 Halflife

Anyhow I'm going to go ahead and say Minecraft. Never before has such a mediocre game been lorded so highly. And the way Notch has been put on this pedestal as one of the industries greatest heros... it's like some kind of real life Talos. Case in point, on this site there was a new article on the main page relating to minecraft every single day for a whole year! They should have renamed the site Escapecraft. I guess we'll see if that kind of rabid overpraise continues when Mojang brings out its next game or whether the fickle nature of the public will result in a flop.
Now, the building aspect is fun, thats why I bought it when it only had the build mode. Then they tried to make a pseudo-survival rpg type...mess. I can't understand why THAT part is popular. Whats fun about stretching out the time it takes to build something and fill it with farming materials while getting killed over and over again? I don't know, its just not fun to me.

And guys, seriously? Some of you can't understand why CoD is so popular? Cmon now, its been years since Modern Warfare 2, we know this already.

=HCFS=Discoman said:
Katawa Shoujo.
Played it, found it badly written, inconsistent, and actually pretty offensive.
Curious. Now, I'm not a fan of jrpg games and dating sims, and find the concept of the game to be just...ridiculous (which translates to most people on the internet to: I'm an insecure, childish call of duty fan and "just don't get it"), but I would like to know what is offensive about it?
 

xPixelatedx

New member
Jan 19, 2011
1,315
0
0
Fable 3
I was a big fan of the original Fable, and after playing the abhorrent sequel, I couldn't for the life of me fathom why anyone would be even a little excited for 3. Sure enough from what I have seen it is also terrible.

Skyward Sword
I am not entierly sure why people were pissing their pants over the trailers. I didn't see a single thing in them that looked exciting. And yes, I am a HUGE Zelda fan. Skyward Sword just looked like Twilight Princess(but not as good) with really washed out colors. Now that the game is out the annoying sword, lack of any overworld and the mandatory motion controls really depress me. I would say no sale, but I am unfortunate enough to have already bought and played it. I can't believe this game is getting perfect 10s. But then again every game gets a perfect 10 now. People are just too damned excited about new things apparently.

Half Life 2
Cool, claustrophobic yet complex level design? Nope.
Amazing, new abominations from beyond the stars around every corner? Nope.
It killed the game for me that these things from HL1 were absent, mostly because I was looking for these exclusively. Overall it was an ok game, but it didn't even feel like an actual sequel, it just felt like a tech demo for their new engine with a Half Life theme added. I just wanted imagination, and instead of got what felt like a thinly veiled war shooter out in the country. Fighting other humanoids with guns was the most boring part of HL1, and HL2 was all about that, yuck.
 

CityofTreez

New member
Sep 2, 2011
367
0
0
Casey Bowen said:
Fallout 3.... I was falling asleep through that game. The movement was clunky, the gameplay was stale, the VO was bad, the main story was un-interesting.

Funny -- 'cause I loved FO3 for the most part. But I hated New Vegas.

'Tis interesting how people can react so differently to such a variety of games.
I liked NV but hated Fallout 3. I put 25hrs into F3 and it didn't a damn thing for me.
 

Don Savik

New member
Aug 27, 2011
913
0
0
Metalhandkerchief said:
Guild Wars 2 and Tera.

The first one, everyone is expecting fireworks and a totally groundbreaking MMO, and so far, all the people I know in beta are completely indifferent to it because it's as bog standard as it gets.

The former, because this douche of a company has engineered the perfect titillating *shell* of a game to max out their appeal with pre-pedo teenagers who are just breaking puberty, and GROWN MEN are going to play it. GROWN MEN! That they aren't embarrassed to play that shit is beyond comprehension. Also, it is a really bad game, judging from beta. Full of bugs and shallowness.
First of all, they're entire race looks like that, and little girls don't have huge thighs like that, and they don't have males, so its ok to fantasize about screwing pre-pubescent looking girls. Its totally normal, sheesh.

^is basically what I have heard for defense of the loli race. Its quite pathetic to be honest. And I think it suffers the same problem Dragon Age 2 had with its combat. Making it actiony just made it so that you have to constantly spam buttons instead of auto-attack.

And in defense of Guild Wars 2, we can all see exactly whats its like from the footage and its quite different in many, many aspects from the traditional mmo. Just because a few people in the UNFINISHED BETA are a bit grumpy, doesn't mean we should automatically listen to their opinions without question. Does it have too much hype? All mmos do because everyone demands it kill WoW.
 

TehCookie

Elite Member
Sep 16, 2008
3,922
0
41
Mass Effect 3, there was just warning flags going off in my head that it was going to be disappointing and yet it was hyped and failed to meet expectations. I just want to scream "how are you surprised?!"

Also Duke Nukem Forever, I can kind of understand the hype of him returning but I didn't get the unrealistic expectations of it being the best shooter. It's Duke Nukem, I don't recall it being better than any shooter, just shooting aliens with adult humor. And my adult humor I mean thinks that please your inner middle schooler who laughs at crudely drawn penises.

I guess it's less of people being excited over a certain game since people have different taste but how/why do they have such unreasonable expectations and think it's going to be the best thing ever or change gaming.
 

thejackyl

New member
Apr 16, 2008
721
0
0
I never understood the hype behind the following series: (Warning: Wall o' Text Ahead.

Halo - It's a competent game, but I've played 1 and 2 and I found them completely boring, and the large maps are easy to get lost in. The multiplayer can be fun, but I personally think ANY multiplayer has more to do with the people you play with more than the game. Unless you play online, and then it's the community as a whole.

Gears of War - Big burly men in powered armor with a chainsaw-rifle fighting humanoid aliens... Again, a competent game, but as Yahtzee said in his review for 3 (or was it 2?) The only level I really remember in the series is the inside of the worm, mainly since that's one location that isn't visited too often. Online multiplayer is extremely lag-infested (1 and 2), and split screen multiplayer is boring (2v2 at the most is SERIOUSLY boring in any shooter imo)

Any military shooter that came out after CoD4 - Most shooters that came out before CoD4 had some form of bizarre or unique appeal to it(Most didn't try to be real or modern. Most 'real' shooters were based on WW2, and most 'modern' shooters took place in an alternate reality.). And really military shooters didn't get really popular until after CoD4 (I didn't hear my friends talking about any shooter apart from Halo, to be fair), and every game since than has been the same formula that CoD4 had but with added cheese and one-ups-manship. I understand that some people like the over-the-top stories. But what gets me is that people will pay $60 for what is essentially an expansion pack for the multiplayer.

For those of you saying Skyrim, it's essentially a Role Player's wet dream. After the tutorial you're free to be your character. Though I wish the game didn't make you into the world-savior from the get go. I think it would be much more interesting if you start as a nobody but as you progress the story your actions turn you into the world-savior, and not just "Hey, you're the PC you're the Dragonborn."
 

Don Savik

New member
Aug 27, 2011
913
0
0
ImmortalDrifter said:
Ahhh this good old thread. Where people can come to pretend that they weren't excited by games that didn't live up to their expectations. Or, to simply be hipsters who rail against popular games that they might even like, for the sake of not appearing akin to one of those sheep that actually fucking enjoys something that someone else does.

What is the point of this thread? Sure fandom gets out of control but why is worth it to say you didn't like how excited other people were?

Since I'm here.

Timesplitters was terrible, how anyone like it is beyond me.
Portal was valve stealing ideas from indie game studios and taking the credit.
The witcher 2 is the single most boring thing to ever come out of the human imagination.
Half Life 2 was a vanilla shooter with a vanilla plot delivered in a way that made it impossible to realize how stale it actually was.
Deus Ex might have actually been compelling as a fucking book.
Baldurs Gate 2 was like Diablo with all of the interesting bits ripped out.

How any of these abominations deserve any hype is completely out of my range of comprehension. Anyone who likes any of these games obviously has no taste and should go back to playing CoD or something.
I love the hate for Half Life. I can't explain it, and I'm not trying to be a condescending asshole (it comes naturally) but I find it hilarious how hipster people try to be to....put themselves on a pedestal of self-riteousness? I don't understand why they do it to be honest. I agree with your points though, this thread is just a fandumb fight.

And the whole "I don't get why triple A shooters aimed at casual-gaming college males". Please quit it. You know why those games sell lots of copies, you aren't fooling anyone. So you don't like Call of Duty. FASCINATING. I bet you're the pinnacle of human intelligence then.
 

Black Arrow Officer

New member
Jun 20, 2011
676
0
0
Fallout: New Vegas. I loved Fallout 3, but for whatever reason New Vegas was a complete flop for me. If Obsidian took an extra year in development to fix the broken quests, ugly enviroments, and all of the other problems, it would be GOMLT (Game of my life time). But for now it serves as my coaster.

This huge-ass rant summarizes my feelings for FO:NV
http://blog.wilshipley.com/2011/01/why-i-hate-new-vegas.html
 

Killspre

New member
Aug 8, 2011
115
0
0
Dragon Age, I don't know why this got so much hype. Its gameplay is boring to look at and is so slow. Its story is so cliched and blatantly steals from other fantasy stories. Only one or two areas did I like but they are few and far between. So I could never understand the hype for this game.
 

=HCFS=Discoman

New member
Jan 1, 2010
178
0
0
Don Savik said:
Djinn8 said:
In b4 Halflife

Anyhow I'm going to go ahead and say Minecraft. Never before has such a mediocre game been lorded so highly. And the way Notch has been put on this pedestal as one of the industries greatest heros... it's like some kind of real life Talos. Case in point, on this site there was a new article on the main page relating to minecraft every single day for a whole year! They should have renamed the site Escapecraft. I guess we'll see if that kind of rabid overpraise continues when Mojang brings out its next game or whether the fickle nature of the public will result in a flop.
Now, the building aspect is fun, thats why I bought it when it only had the build mode. Then they tried to make a pseudo-survival rpg type...mess. I can't understand why THAT part is popular. Whats fun about stretching out the time it takes to build something and fill it with farming materials while getting killed over and over again? I don't know, its just not fun to me.

And guys, seriously? Some of you can't understand why CoD is so popular? Cmon now, its been years since Modern Warfare 2, we know this already.

=HCFS=Discoman said:
Katawa Shoujo.
Played it, found it badly written, inconsistent, and actually pretty offensive.
Curious. Now, I'm not a fan of jrpg games and dating sims, and find the concept of the game to be just...ridiculous (which translates to most people on the internet to: I'm an insecure, childish call of duty fan and "just don't get it"), but I would like to know what is offensive about it?
well, to start with, the name is actually offensive. As in, katawa is a word you can't actually say on tv or radio in Japan. While it loosely translates to imperfect girls, a more accurate translation is 'gimp chicks.'
Another thing is it is supposed to treat the girls and their respective issues with a lot of respect, and it, well, doesn't.
If they wanted to treat issues seriously, they could have started by not using the male character with what seems to be severe schizophrenia as comic relief.
for a game that wasn't supposed to sexualize the girls, you have a bonus option where you collect CGs of the sex scenes with the girls. Images that can be later used as fap material.
Each character path was done by a different writer, with the result that the main character is cold and uncaring in one path, and warm and friendly in another. It's as if the writers didn't consolidate how the main character is supposed to be-different paths create conflicting ideas of how the main character is.

I like the idea behind it though. A Visual Novel (KS is a Visual Novel, not a dating sim. instead of explaining the difference, KS is a Visual Novel, College Romance: Rise of the Little Brother is a Dating Sim.) that uses characters that would never see the light of day in a normal VN, such as the large-breasted girl with odd color hair. No, wait, they have one of those. But they don't have the shy girl who is insecure about something and hides from the protagonist as a result, but later warms up to them. No, wait, they have that too. The characters are basically the standard Visual Novel characters, but someone scribbled 'They're Disabled!' in the margins of the characters sheets.

Sorry if that turned a little ranty.
 

Don Savik

New member
Aug 27, 2011
913
0
0
=HCFS=Discoman said:
snip

well, to start with, the name is actually offensive. As in, katawa is a word you can't actually say on tv or radio in Japan. While it loosely translates to imperfect girls, a more accurate translation is 'gimp chicks.'
Another thing is it is supposed to treat the girls and their respective issues with a lot of respect, and it, well, doesn't.
If they wanted to treat issues seriously, they could have started by not using the male character with what seems to be severe schizophrenia as comic relief.
for a game that wasn't supposed to sexualize the girls, you have a bonus option where you collect CGs of the sex scenes with the girls. Images that can be later used as fap material.
Each character path was done by a different writer, with the result that the main character is cold and uncaring in one path, and warm and friendly in another. It's as if the writers didn't consolidate how the main character is supposed to be-different paths create conflicting ideas of how the main character is.

I like the idea behind it though. A Visual Novel (KS is a Visual Novel, not a dating sim. instead of explaining the difference, KS is a Visual Novel, College Romance: Rise of the Little Brother is a Dating Sim.) that uses characters that would never see the light of day in a normal VN, such as the large-breasted girl with odd color hair. No, wait, they have one of those. But they don't have the shy girl who is insecure about something and hides from the protagonist as a result, but later warms up to them. No, wait, they have that too. The characters are basically the standard Visual Novel characters, but someone scribbled 'They're Disabled!' in the margins of the characters sheets.

Sorry if that turned a little ranty.
Interesting, and I don't mind rants at all :) I think the art doesn't do the concept justice. They look too plasticy, and the removal of an arm or making one blind doesn't fix this. I don't understand why people who like these games can't see why others are turned off by the overall concept. Its not that people dismiss it because we think people who play them are losers (I myself have never had a girlfriend and am quite awkward, you'd think the ideal target for these kinds of games) its just looks like the game was trying to justify its concept for no reason other than to be different. It seems like everyone was trying to advertise it as being revolutionary as far as VNs go, but by doing so turned out to be other standard VN that just happens to deal with cripples. I don't see any part of the concept enjoyable. People say the characters are troubled and complicated which means its instantly a facsinating game, but having a dark and troubled character is just as cliche as a static character. Troubled angsty teens aren't any more deep and thought provoking than average ordinary adults.

I would like to explain my thoughts to my friend, who I've seen playing it recently, but sadly he is the kind (like most on the internet) to dismiss my thoughts because "I just don't get it" because apparently you have to be a deep, emotional, and extroidinary human being to understand these games. *rolls eyes* I think the pretentiousness of the genre's fans is what drives people away to be honest.
 

betafotball

New member
Apr 3, 2012
17
0
0
Battlefield 3. A lot of people talked about how it was going to break call of duty and that didn´t really work out.

Final Fantasy. There has been so many now I cannot understand why some people still get all worked up about the next installment.

Call of duty. I won´t even say something about COD.
 

=HCFS=Discoman

New member
Jan 1, 2010
178
0
0
Don Savik said:
=HCFS=Discoman said:
snip

well, to start with, the name is actually offensive. As in, katawa is a word you can't actually say on tv or radio in Japan. While it loosely translates to imperfect girls, a more accurate translation is 'gimp chicks.'
Another thing is it is supposed to treat the girls and their respective issues with a lot of respect, and it, well, doesn't.
If they wanted to treat issues seriously, they could have started by not using the male character with what seems to be severe schizophrenia as comic relief.
for a game that wasn't supposed to sexualize the girls, you have a bonus option where you collect CGs of the sex scenes with the girls. Images that can be later used as fap material.
Each character path was done by a different writer, with the result that the main character is cold and uncaring in one path, and warm and friendly in another. It's as if the writers didn't consolidate how the main character is supposed to be-different paths create conflicting ideas of how the main character is.

I like the idea behind it though. A Visual Novel (KS is a Visual Novel, not a dating sim. instead of explaining the difference, KS is a Visual Novel, College Romance: Rise of the Little Brother is a Dating Sim.) that uses characters that would never see the light of day in a normal VN, such as the large-breasted girl with odd color hair. No, wait, they have one of those. But they don't have the shy girl who is insecure about something and hides from the protagonist as a result, but later warms up to them. No, wait, they have that too. The characters are basically the standard Visual Novel characters, but someone scribbled 'They're Disabled!' in the margins of the characters sheets.

Sorry if that turned a little ranty.
Interesting, and I don't mind rants at all :) I think the art doesn't do the concept justice. They look too plasticy, and the removal of an arm or making one blind doesn't fix this. I don't understand why people who like these games can't see why others are turned off by the overall concept. Its not that people dismiss it because we think people who play them are losers (I myself have never had a girlfriend and am quite awkward, you'd think the ideal target for these kinds of games) its just looks like the game was trying to justify its concept for no reason other than to be different. It seems like everyone was trying to advertise it as being revolutionary as far as VNs go, but by doing so turned out to be other standard VN that just happens to deal with cripples. I don't see any part of the concept enjoyable. People say the characters are troubled and complicated which means its instantly a facsinating game, but having a dark and troubled character is just as cliche as a static character. Troubled angsty teens aren't any more deep and thought provoking than average ordinary adults.

I would like to explain my thoughts to my friend, who I've seen playing it recently, but sadly he is the kind (like most on the internet) to dismiss my thoughts because "I just don't get it" because apparently you have to be a deep, emotional, and extroidinary human being to understand these games. *rolls eyes* I think the pretentiousness of the genre's fans is what drives people away to be honest.
Yeah, I found that as well. they tried to be different with something that really didn't make a difference, but they got a lot of hard-core fans who will defend it to the death.
Nicely enough, most gamers on, well, game sites and not VN sites seem to be rational about this, but man, you should see the, for lack of a better word, shitstorm that happens when a VN reviewer calls it out.
 

Elamdri

New member
Nov 19, 2009
1,480
0
0
Zhukov said:
I never understood the hype for Tetris.

The story sucked and the gameplay was the usual shallow modern crap, but everyone just goes on about it being a "classic". Must be nostalgia at work!

And don't even get me started on Asteroids...

...

These threads get under my skin something fierce. They turn up like clockwork about once a fortnight and are made of nothing but whinging, insecurity and supreme arrogance.

Also, stop liking things I don't like. Don't you all know how rude that is?
I like you. When I rule the world, you will be one of the last to die.