That's not true. There's no fun in playing hockey single-player... poker, settlers, chess, monopoly... and to be honest there are better or worse games to play with friends. Some aren't enjoyable at all because the mechanics just suck the fun out of doing anything with 'em.Shjade said:"If a game is only fun when you and your friends do it together then that's a review of your friends, not the game." <-- exactly the point I was making in the Borderlands review comments.
lol some people actually like MMO-style gameplay on its own merits, regardless of if it's in a MMO or not.Jaredin said:Yeah, I never got anti-social people on MMOs...its like, what is the point?
Actually, I just enjoy the humor of your reviews. I don't mind if you make fun of games I enjoy; I prefer you trash every game rather than rave about a game that is very poorly made. However, Borderlands is a good deal better crafted than some of the games you have raved about.Yahtzee Croshaw said:Because as angsty loners it's important that you pay attention to us.
This presupposes that the primary purpose of every game is to entertain a single person. This is demonstrably false. Many games cannot be played meaningfully with a single person. For example, most card games, board games, pen and paper RPGs, and even sports would all be impossible to play as designed without other people. If judged as a single-player experience, they would not even qualify as valid games. Why should video games be any different?Just to repeat myself (again), all games must stand up on its single-player.
Certainly there's a subjective nature to enjoyment of a game. In a single-player experience, you're the only variable, and your bias is presumed to be a major contributing factor in your opinion. In a multiplayer experience, every other player is a variable as well and can change the final impression. In that sense, you are correct. But the game plays the same role in the formula regardless of the number of players. If judging a multiplayer game was *only* judging your friends, then we would like all multiplayer games equally from Smash Bros to Poker to D&D.If a game is only fun when you and your friends do it together then that's a review of your friends, not the game.
Have you seen TF2 after one of these updates? It's much better now as you can just get the weapons randomly through normal gameplay, as any class, or join an achievement server, but it was horrible before.Abedeus said:"Complain, complain, no nerdrage is bad, complain, TF2 complains, CONTENT IS BAD COMPLAINS".
Seriously? You complain that they've kept the game healthy and fresh after over two years? That they keep giving players new, fun maps, new weapons to promote different styles and roles for classes?