The horns serve a few purposes. The first, an army doesn't operate like a hive mind, and there were a lot of Rohirrim there. The horns help coordinate them. The second, it lets their presence be known to the men inside Minas Tirrith, enabling them to launch a counter attack as the Rohirrim charge (it's been a while since I read the books, but I have an impression that this was the moment when Prince Imrahil led the Swan Knights on a sortie). The third, scares the crap out of the enemies. The Orc army was massive, and there was no way they'd be able to relocate enough pikemen and archers to form a solid wall before the Rohirrim hit. The horns do a great job of spreading the fear to the entire enemy army.Scorched_Cascade said:I always thought it was rather nice of them to announce their presence with war horns and then form up in plain sight allowing the Orcs to reorganise their ranks and deploy pikemen to the new front rather than just smashing into the flank of the host that was focused in the other direction.
I guess what they did was more honourable or something but what I would have done would have minimised friendly casualties, maximised enemy casualties and had a fairly devastating affect on morale (trained horsemen out of fucking nowhere? Aww hell no)
LOTR has so many great speeches in it but that would have to be my favourite too. Probably my favourite scene in any of those movies.Lionsfan said:I always really dug this speech and ensuing charge:
Really one of the coolest moments in cinema
I forgot until now how good an actor robin williams actually is. He can make you literally roll around the floor laughing then without a moments notice he can put a great big lump in your throatIndianaJonny said:It's the calm, quite ones that surprise you.
Guess you could say there's a man who's not squandered his talent.shootthebandit said:I forgot until now how good an actor robin williams actually is. He can make you literally roll around the floor laughing then without a moments notice he can put a great big lump in your throat
Scorched_Cascade said:There really is only one choice for me that I can think of at the moment.
What he says, how he says it...gave me chills the first time.
I always thought it was rather nice of them to announce their presence with war horns and then form up in plain sight allowing the Orcs to reorganise their ranks and deploy pikemen to the new front rather than just smashing into the flank of the host that was focused in the other direction.Lionsfan said:I always really dug this speech and ensuing charge:
Really one of the coolest moments in cinema
I guess what they did was more honourable or something but what I would have done would have minimised friendly casualties, maximised enemy casualties and had a fairly devastating affect on morale (trained horsemen out of fucking nowhere? Aww hell no)