There's also the fact that while he DOES know his movies (I listened to the extra credits episode he helped co-write and it was pretty good actually), he's not so good on games.
I stopped taking the Overthinker (Which I used to really like) seriously at all after he defended Other M and then doubled down on it. I mean, GOD, how does someone miss the broadside of the barn that badly?
If anyone wants to complain about bad female representation in games, it should START with how Samus went from a strong, thoughful/introspective independent bounty hunter able to confront her fears (and with a rare soft side) into -> An overly emotional wuss who somehow suddenly loved taking orders and being under Adam's thumb the whole time, who was too unable to function on her own that she never thought to go "Oy, Adam, I'm in a volcano area, mind if I turn on the Varia suit? I mean, it's heat protection not a weapon that threatens the stability of the station, right" and who on confronting her arch nemesis (Who she has killed between 2-5 times by this point) instead of arming up to fight (or even snapping into a berserk "How many times do I have to kill you?!" rage), she breaks down like a child. -_-
I mean, that's a textbook case of ruining one of the first and best female heroes in games, and the only way he could have missed the point harder is if he'd deliberately aimed in the wrong direction and the point was in another country altogether. I'm still flummoxed by the whole thing.