Homefront Reviews - Average so far... 72%

Recommended Videos

ChildofGallifrey

New member
May 26, 2008
1,095
0
0
I see that it's getting a lot of (possibly deserved) ire for being 'generic'. Like many others have said already, none of us (probably) have played it yet, so we don't know how generic it really is. I'm saying that to be fair, because I personally think it'll be a pretty standard FPS, but we don't know yet.

Also, a good friend's husband works for Kaos, so I'm inclined to be charitable towards the game.
 

Ironic Pirate

New member
May 21, 2009
5,541
0
0
ZombieGenesis said:
What's that? An overmarketed generic FPS gets a 9/10?

Stop the presses, I wanna get off.

I really love formulaic comments calling a game generic. Pot, kettle.

I'm going to wait to actually play the game before making edgy, jaded comments about it.
 

Korten12

Now I want ma...!
Aug 26, 2009
10,766
0
0
Dr. McD said:
Homefront has:

Regenerating health COD didn't invent Regen Health

Soldiers and Vehicles as enemies, mostly soldiers. This is universal for a lot of games

CoD controls. Why fix what isn't broken?

Portrayal of bad guys committing atrocities. In COD that doesn't happen often, quite rerely.

Guns that sound like rapid firing staplers.Uh... What?

Oh, and I forgot to mention you fight alongside invincible NPC allies in both as well.This is because it would be stupid if Key NPCs died...
Response in your quote. Try again.
 

Korten12

Now I want ma...!
Aug 26, 2009
10,766
0
0
Ironic Pirate said:
ZombieGenesis said:
What's that? An overmarketed generic FPS gets a 9/10?

Stop the presses, I wanna get off.

I really love formulaic comments calling a game generic. Pot, kettle.

I'm going to wait to actually play the game before making edgy, jaded comments about it.
But thats in the Escapist's nature, judge before actually playing. I mean why would you play a game then judge it...
 

VanityGirl

New member
Apr 29, 2009
3,471
0
0
Ah I love the people on this site.

I shall now go buy the game just because it is recieving so much hate already. :) I bathe in the hate of others.
 

inFAMOUSCowZ

New member
Jul 12, 2010
1,586
0
0
I'm waiting to see some more, and get an overall idea for the game. Since my B-day is monday, I might pick it up that week. I just wanna know if the multi-is any good since, FPS single players tend to be fun the first time through.
 

Cowabungaa

New member
Feb 10, 2008
10,804
0
0
VanityGirl said:
Ah I love the people on this site.

I shall now go buy the game just because it is recieving so much hate already. :) I bath in the hate of others.
The funniest thing about is that apparently none of the haters takes the effort of actually arguing with the reasons that many professional reviewers gave this game such high scores. All I see is "these scores are high, this is bullshit" instead of actually looking at the reviews and dissecting them. Now if they did that and gave some good arguments against it, that'd be okay, but right now we just see flaming.
 

VanityGirl

New member
Apr 29, 2009
3,471
0
0
Cowabungaa said:
VanityGirl said:
Ah I love the people on this site.

I shall now go buy the game just because it is recieving so much hate already. :) I bath in the hate of others.
The funniest thing about is that apparently none of the haters takes the effort of actually arguing with the reasons that many professional reviewers gave this game such high scores. All I see is "these scores are high, this is bullshit" instead of actually looking at the reviews and dissecting them. Now if they did that and gave some good arguments against it, that'd be okay, but right now we just see flaming.
Just enjoy it, bathe in the hatred of other people.
TO be honest, I know little to nothing about this game.
 

Korten12

Now I want ma...!
Aug 26, 2009
10,766
0
0
Cowabungaa said:
VanityGirl said:
Ah I love the people on this site.

I shall now go buy the game just because it is recieving so much hate already. :) I bath in the hate of others.
The funniest thing about is that apparently none of the haters takes the effort of actually arguing with the reasons that many professional reviewers gave this game such high scores. All I see is "these scores are high, this is bullshit" instead of actually looking at the reviews and dissecting them. Now if they did that and gave some good arguments against it, that'd be okay, but right now we just see flaming.
Agreed. Half of them see the scores and don't even look at the review itself. If you look at the XboxAddcit review, while myself only read tid bits. Its actually really long compared to most reviews. 19 long paragraphs from what I counted.

Hell the spanish review is 4 pages long. I doubt if the game wasn't really good. They wouldn't have put so much effort into the reviews.
 

HK_01

New member
Jun 1, 2009
1,610
0
0
thefreeman0001 said:
well i watched ten minutes of homefront and at 5 minutes or so into the vid my stomach clenched up at one moment friggen horrible emotional manipulation. so now im really intrested no game has made me go "...the hell did i just...did he just shot a ki...HE DID!!" so yeah lol watching out for it.

bam in this video

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bEI0uMutFVs
Thanks for the link! Now this game looks even worse! This really reminded me of the current "Critical Miss". I mean, what the hell?

Korean soldier 1: Hey, you know, I don't think the player quite got the idea that we're EVIL from seeing our guys randomly beat up civilians and shooting people attempting to flee yet. How 'bout we shoot those child's parents to make sure he knows we're the antagonists?
Korean soldier 2: Great idea! There's no reason for it, but who cares, we are EVIL after all! I mean, sure, we could also deport them like all the others, but if we shoot them that'll be really good for the atmosphere since they have a child and whatnot!
Korean soldier 1: Yeah, that was the best idea I've ever had! Too bad we can't execute the child 'cause children aren't allowed to die in video games...that would've been even EVILer!


Seriously, why not just give them horns and glowing eyes?
 

Miko101

New member
Apr 9, 2009
1
0
0
This game suffers from a few things. Its trying to be 3 things at once. Well really only 2 but it seems like 3

It's pulling a Red Dawn from the other side of the United states and making the player character a Gordon Freeman while trying to be a military shooter in the likeness of Call of Duty 4 and beyond while also being a hitscan game like say counterstrike or day of defeat.

It's trying to be all these and can't decide on which one to be and it's foundation is collapsing on each other because it has nothing to say for itself in terms of the single player.

The Multiplayer has to be really really damn good to save this game from being a devastating failure in my opinion.
 

DVS Storm

New member
Jul 13, 2009
307
0
0
It is a COD clone. Why does every game want to be like COD(well obvious answer but still)?
 

Saucycarpdog

New member
Sep 30, 2009
3,258
0
0
HK_01 said:
thefreeman0001 said:
well i watched ten minutes of homefront and at 5 minutes or so into the vid my stomach clenched up at one moment friggen horrible emotional manipulation. so now im really intrested no game has made me go "...the hell did i just...did he just shot a ki...HE DID!!" so yeah lol watching out for it.

bam in this video

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bEI0uMutFVs
Thanks for the link! Now this game looks even worse! This really reminded me of the current "Critical Miss". I mean, what the hell?

Korean soldier 1: Hey, you know, I don't think the player quite got the idea that we're EVIL from seeing our guys randomly beat up civilians and shooting people attempting to flee yet. How 'bout we shoot those child's parents to make sure he knows we're the antagonists?
Korean soldier 2: Great idea! There's no reason for it, but who cares, we are EVIL after all! I mean, sure, we could also deport them like all the others, but if we shoot them that'll be really good for the atmosphere since they have a child and whatnot!
Korean soldier 1: Yeah, that was the best idea I've ever had! Too bad we can't execute the child 'cause children aren't allowed to die in video games...that would've been even EVILer!


Seriously, why not just give them horns and glowing eyes?
I'm sorry, I didn't know that games that try to bring in real emotion suck. I'll remember to bash every game this year that has even an ounce of emotion in it. Thanks for the tip!
 

repeating integers

New member
Mar 17, 2010
3,314
0
0
HK_01 said:
thefreeman0001 said:
well i watched ten minutes of homefront and at 5 minutes or so into the vid my stomach clenched up at one moment friggen horrible emotional manipulation. so now im really intrested no game has made me go "...the hell did i just...did he just shot a ki...HE DID!!" so yeah lol watching out for it.

bam in this video

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bEI0uMutFVs
Thanks for the link! Now this game looks even worse! This really reminded me of the current "Critical Miss". I mean, what the hell?

Korean soldier 1: Hey, you know, I don't think the player quite got the idea that we're EVIL from seeing our guys randomly beat up civilians and shooting people attempting to flee yet. How 'bout we shoot those child's parents to make sure he knows we're the antagonists?
Korean soldier 2: Great idea! There's no reason for it, but who cares, we are EVIL after all! I mean, sure, we could also deport them like all the others, but if we shoot them that'll be really good for the atmosphere since they have a child and whatnot!
Korean soldier 1: Yeah, that was the best idea I've ever had! Too bad we can't execute the child 'cause children aren't allowed to die in video games...that would've been even EVILer!


Seriously, why not just give them horns and glowing eyes?
So I assume you were also unimpressed with the sections in Half-life 2 involving metrocops beating up random civilians, and massacring a captured and defenceless resistance cell with machinegun fire?

(Of course, it could be you're one of the comparatively uncommon Escapists who didn't like/hasn't played HL2, but in that case my point still stands for other people.)
 

HK_01

New member
Jun 1, 2009
1,610
0
0
Saucycardog said:
I'm sorry, I didn't know that games that try to bring in real emotion suck. I'll remember to bash every game this year that has even an ounce of emotion in it. Thanks for the tip!
That's not emotion. Well, it is, but it's achieved through very blatant manipulation. It's about the same "emotion" as the shooting of civilians on an airport in MW2, or having a scene where puppies are shoveled into an oven. The Koreans are simply depicted as almost comically evil in this game.
 

Nomanslander

New member
Feb 21, 2009
2,962
0
0
Saucycardog said:
As much as these reviews look good, I can already see people still coming into this thread and trolling about how homefront looks stupid.

Btw, did XboxAddict just post that review?
Hey, what can you do, the first 4 seconds it takes to build any first impression will always out weigh the impression made in the long run...=/

Anyways, the only reason some of you keep making threads about this game is because you think it's been unfairly miss judged, if it hadn't been you might not have even been interested in the first place.
 

Xanadu84

New member
Apr 9, 2008
2,946
0
0
I actually expect the game to be good. From what I see, it looks polished with a fun setting. I do want to play it. However, I can definitely wait until it drops in price. Why? Well, no matter how good it is, it will probably ring of Call of Duty. Modern day military shooter, with all the details that we have come to expect of that genre. I'm sure Homefront will add its own elements to make it fun and unique, deserving the title of something more then, "Clone", but still, I have the recent Call of Duty's and Battlefield. Even if Homefront is better then both, it's still treading some similar ground. The campaign will likely be short, because a game like that requires a constant string of detailed set pieces, and the tropes will probably be familiar. I'm sure that I will enjoy the campaign, but that's still a lot of money for an inevitably short campaign. Games of this genre generally are strongest in the multiplayer arena, and in addition to already needing to play more Black Ops and Battlefield: BC2, I am interested in Crysis 2, that will add another COD-like multiplayer. The CoD style multiplayer is great, the popularity of it if anything should be an indication of its strength. However, no matter how much you love Chinese food, having it for breakfast, lunch and dinner will get on your nerves. I have other COD-like formats for multiplayer, and Crysis 2 multiplayer will be enough for oversaturation to begin with (I mainly want Crysis 2 for the single player). That will make Homefront multiplayer completely redundant, and it wouuld not be realistic of me to expect Homefront single player to be strong enough, in a sea of games with similar tone, , to justify the starting price. Let it come down in price, and Ill enjoy it.
 

Saucycarpdog

New member
Sep 30, 2009
3,258
0
0
HK_01 said:
Saucycardog said:
I'm sorry, I didn't know that games that try to bring in real emotion suck. I'll remember to bash every game this year that has even an ounce of emotion in it. Thanks for the tip!
That's not emotion. Well, it is, but it's achieved through very blatant manipulation. It's about the same "emotion" as the shooting of civilians on an airport in MW2, or having a scene where puppies are shoveled into an oven. The Koreans are simply depicted as almost comically evil in this game.
Well this is a FPS and not a RPG, so it has to take certain liberties to try to build character and emotion. Besides, that was just the beggining of the game so there is probably much more focused and defined emotion in the rest of the game since they now have the exposition covered.
 

repeating integers

New member
Mar 17, 2010
3,314
0
0
On reviews:

MS-XBOX-WORLD (nice of their logo to leave out all punctuation, forcing me to insert some) review didn't impress me that much, to be honest. They devoted the majority of the review to the singleplayer, with the result that I now know how good the campaign is but know little of the multiplayer. In a game like this, which is clearly trying to succeed in both the SP and MP aspect (like Halo), I think equal portions of the review should be devoted to both.

Also, they score a game based on the following categories:

Gameplay
Graphics
Sound
Longevity

...something is missing from that list. Beginning with S.

XboxAddict has the same problem when it comes to lacking a "story" subcategory, but on the other hand they covered that lots in the written review. In fact, the written review was brilliant. It covered all the reasons why he liked the game and backed up his arguments. I'll be looking at XboxAddict's reviews from now on. I also think I'm gonna try Homefront.

So basically, Haters: look at the reviews before spouting your indignant rhetoric. Don't make baseless assumptions. You come across as arrogant idiots half the time (at least).
 

theultimateend

New member
Nov 1, 2007
3,621
0
0
IBlackKiteI said:
ZombieGenesis said:
What's that? An overmarketed generic FPS gets a 9/10?

Stop the presses, I wanna get off.
Thats actually a damn good score for a new IP.

Halo and Call of Duty will ALWAYS get a 9 or higher, because they're Halo and Call of Duty.

And whenever I see someone use the term 'generic' in regards to any game that features guns, a little more faith in this site dies in me.
Because, after all, this website dictates who can and cannot post.