Oblivion: Wow, just....wow.
I fell in love with Skyrim so much that I became interested in wanting to know what came before, so I gave it a try. Between the bizarre, distorted NPC faces in psychedelic orange lighting, the strange, slightly-muffled quality of the sound, the weird way many female NPCs sounded like men imitating women's voices (seriously, I'm convinced that was going on), the male-looking body modeling, the painfully, excruciatingly-slow crawl to be effective...it must be what being on a drug trip is like. I've put about 50 hours into it (forcing myself by the end), and I just can't do it anymore.
The raving, glowing praise, coupled with the aggressive Skyrim slamming, makes me think there's some serious nostalgia-goggles going on, and I really, *really* wanted to like it. Despite this, I'm still a little curious to go further back and try ES3, but I don't know.
Fable 3: Worst let-down of all time for us.
By 'us' I mean my boyfriend and I. We both really liked Fable 2 (and he liked Fable), and were really looking forward to the co-op feature in 3, as well as the game in general. Whoever thought it would be a brilliant idea to remove menus entirely, and force you to go through a series of physical rooms to make even the most trivial of changes to your character, should never be allowed near a game again. The character mechanic gets into its own way so profoundly that it's spoiled the game as a whole for us.
And that's not mentioning the game-breaking bugs. We didn't even get through the first main quest-mission before several glitches broke the game, forcing us to start over. Overall, just awful. It's a text-book example of DON'T TRY TO BE OVERLY CLEVER AND REINVENT THE WHEEL.