And this is why the industry as a whole cannot be taken seriously. A critical reviewer should not base his scoring or final review on merely his opinion alone. He needs to critically examine the product, and it is absolutely necessary to view the flaws involved. Whether or not a game is "fun" to the reviewer is absolutely meaningless. I absolutely love games that are frankly god-awful or mediocre at best (Quest 64, the original Fable, Conquest: Frontier Wars, etc). That does not make them good or great games.Capitano Segnaposto said:Oh good lord. They have their own opinion that you don't agree with, get over it. That is the problem with any reviewer, the readers may not agree with the opinion, please read that one word over and over again: OPINION, of the REVIEWER. Here let me review some games: Killzone is a generic shooter, Call of Duty Modern Warfare 3 was a great shooter, and I despise the warhammer games. Was it a good review? Hell no. Did you agree with it? Maybe, maybe not. Review is just a fancy word for opinion and people need to get the hell over it and stop bitching about, "Oh no! They liked/hated a game/movie/song/book that I hated/liked! Now to bash them for having an OPINION. Surely that sounds stupid to some of you right?thememan said:I find the bigger problem being them giving perfect or near perfect scores to games that are clearly and fundamentally flawed, that one cannot even fathom having such a high score.
The problem is that serious reviewers need to take off the rose-tinted glasses of their fanboyism and actually critically review the products. Which they do not. Certain aspect transcend "opinion", as a mediocre game is a mediocre game whether or not you enjoyed it. Certainly a degree of subjectivism will always be present, as it is impossible to completely remove one's personal tastes and opinions. However they are purely within the non-critical realm of review. This type of review is completely unprofessional. It is nothing more than being equal to any number of fan made youtube videos or reviews. And yet they claim to be professionals, selling a professional product. Quite frankly, if they want to be considered seriously they need to act as such. They are not supposed to be fans of a game, and their enjoyment of the game itself matters little to none. Rather it is expected and demanded of them to approach these products professionally and critically, something that they consistently show they cannot do.