I have nothing to add to this topic, so instead I will respond by giving the exact opposite:
Atlus has always come so close to making games that I should absolutely love, but always find some way or another (sometimes several) to completely drop the ball for me. Given I haven't really played every single Atlus game out there, but that's because I stopped after losing faith in them. Touch Detective came the closest, in that I actually did play it all the way through, but even that kinda left me with a "meh" feeling. Super Robot Taisen just had nothing to offer me, Odin Sphere should, would, and could have been great except that they convoluted things by making them needlessly complicated rather than keeping it simple. Yggdra Union fell prey to the "WTF AM I EVEN TRYING TO DO?!" school of game design. And I really tend to dislike JRPGs, so I didn't bother trying Persona or SMT, etc.
Currently, Atlus, for all its praise and following, has not yet produced anything I have actually fully enjoyed.