Its that time again, Your Top 10 Favorite Games Topic

Fractral

Tentacle God
Feb 28, 2012
1,243
0
0
CarolusRex said:
Pokemon: Black 2
You'd put black 2 above the first? I didn't think it was as good. Actually, you're the first person I've seen do that.
TizzytheTormentor said:
1)Final Fantasy IX (My favorite game of all time)
Awesome! Someone else also puts FFIX first on their list. Seems like that game gets forgotten a lot, overlooked in favour of FFVII and FFVIII. Its a shame, too- it has the best characters and story from almost any game.

OT: I don't have 10.
1) Final Fantasy IX
2) Half Life 2
3) Persona 3
4) Sins of A Solar Empire: Trinity (specifically with the Distant Stars mod, but vanilla is epic too)
5) Pokemon White
 

EmperorSubcutaneous

New member
Dec 22, 2010
857
0
0
You know, I don't think I've ever posted my top 10 here before.

If you're one of the 0 people on this site who know me, you'll know that this list is in "gun to my head" format. Ideally I would allow for ties (which means that there would be an additional 12 games on this list), but since that would be unsporting, here are the 10:

1. Silent Hill 2
2. Riven
3. Journey
4. Ico
5. Guild Wars 2
6. Final Fantasy XI
7. Machinarium
8. Botanicula
9. Aquaria
10. Dragon Age: Origins

Trivia 1: two games on this list (Silent Hill 2 and Ico) both saw their initial release on the same day: September 24th, 2001.
Trivia 2: three games on this list (Journey, Guild Wars 2, and Botanicula) were released in 2012. NO ONE MAKES GOOD GAMES ANYMORE

Things may change when I get around to playing Okami and Prince of Persia: Sands of Time.
 

Terminate421

New member
Jul 21, 2010
5,773
0
0
Fractral said:
CarolusRex said:
Pokemon: Black 2
You'd put black 2 above the first? I didn't think it was as good. Actually, you're the first person I've seen do that.
TizzytheTormentor said:
1)Final Fantasy IX (My favorite game of all time)
Awesome! Someone else also puts FFIX first on their list. Seems like that game gets forgotten a lot, overlooked in favour of FFVII and FFVIII. Its a shame, too- it has the best characters and story from almost any game.

OT: I don't have 10.
1) Final Fantasy IX
2) Half Life 2
3) Persona 3
4) Sins of A Solar Empire: Trinity (specifically with the Distant Stars mod, but vanilla is epic too)
5) Pokemon White
Actually I would as well.

Pokemon World Tournament is fucking awesome. Also the New Team Plasma is cool.
 

ohnoitsabear

New member
Feb 15, 2011
1,236
0
0
Let's see. I'm probably forgetting something major here, but here is my list as of now.

Morrowind
Metroid Prime
Pokemon (no specific game, just the series in general)
Psychonauts
Half Life 2
Mario Kart Double Dash
Nehrim (total conversion mod for Oblivion)
Super Smash Brothers Brawl (might be Melee, but I haven't had a chance to play it in years)
The Binding of Isaac
IVAN (an excellent free rougelike)

And here are a few games that may end up being on the list, but I haven't played enough of to judge yet.

Okami (just got it, and it's amazing)
Demons' Souls (Love it, but I haven't actually finished it yet)
Gothic 2 (same as above)
Planescape Torment (again, haven't actually finished it yet)
Hawken (I'm in the beta, and, with some tweaking, it could easily be in my top ten)
Dishonored (Finished my first playthrough, but I've had too much other stuff to play to see how it holds up on multiple playthroughs)
 

Fractral

Tentacle God
Feb 28, 2012
1,243
0
0
Terminate421 said:
Fractral said:
CarolusRex said:
Pokemon: Black 2
You'd put black 2 above the first? I didn't think it was as good. Actually, you're the first person I've seen do that.
TizzytheTormentor said:
1)Final Fantasy IX (My favorite game of all time)
Awesome! Someone else also puts FFIX first on their list. Seems like that game gets forgotten a lot, overlooked in favour of FFVII and FFVIII. Its a shame, too- it has the best characters and story from almost any game.

OT: I don't have 10.
1) Final Fantasy IX
2) Half Life 2
3) Persona 3
4) Sins of A Solar Empire: Trinity (specifically with the Distant Stars mod, but vanilla is epic too)
5) Pokemon White
Actually I would as well.

Pokemon World Tournament is fucking awesome. Also the New Team Plasma is cool.
I couldn't put my finger on it... yeah, World Tournament is awesome, and yeah the new stuff is cool, but it just lacked something for me. It felt kinda empty, really. Like how after you get to undella town nothing really happens for an hour, you just wind your way through to Opelucid city. It was the most boring part of the game for me. I had the same problem with all of HG/SS- the entire of the Kanto area just felt dead to me.
Though that gym leader who seemed to be permanently stoned was epic. And what happens after you beat Drayden- well, I won't spoil it but it was so awesome. I was so shocked at that.
 

Jodan

New member
Mar 18, 2009
379
0
0
ive never acctually dont one of these and will be surprised if anyone reads this

1. freespace 2
2. freespace 1 (see what i did there)
3. suikoden 3 really any suikoden game
4. any jedi knight game
5. goldeneye (nostalgia)
6. rouge galaxy
7. RTCW
8. kessen 2
9. The Entire Total war series should be higher
10. master of orion 2

special mentions go to freelancer, phonix wright, heroes of might and magic and, ace combat 5
 

Nim

New member
Apr 5, 2012
25
0
0
In unparticular order:

1 American McGee's Alice
2 Alice: Madness Returns
3 Edna & Harvey: Harvey's New Eyes
4 Max Payne
5 Saint's Row 2
6 Bioshock
7 Silent Hill 2
8 Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines
9 Sanitarium
10 The GTA IV video editor. Shut up it counts, because because. D:
 

Nazulu

They will not take our Fluids
Jun 5, 2008
6,242
0
0
Order no particular in:

Super Metroid
Metroid Prime
Half-Life 2
Portal
Starcraft: Brood War
Diablo 2: Lord of Destruction
Super Smash Brothers Melee
C&C Generals
Lineage II (old chronicles)
Star Wars: Shadows of the Empire
 

putowtin

I'd like to purchase an alcohol!
Jul 7, 2010
3,452
0
0
In no particular order

Assassins Creed Series
Mass Effect Series
InFamous Series
KotOR II
Dragon Age: Origins
Saints Row 2
GTA San Andreas
Skyrim
Fallout: New Vegas
Uncharted Series
 

Hollyday

New member
Mar 5, 2012
476
0
0
Although there are some good games on my list, it's mostly down to nostalgia (that's code for 'don't judge me')

1. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
2. Skies of Arcadia
3. Little Big Adventure 2
4. Mass Effect 1
5. Half Life 2
6. Prince of Persia: Sands of Time
7. Grim Fandango
8. Psychonauts
9. Assassin's Creed 2
10. Beyond Good and Evil
 

5-0

New member
Apr 6, 2010
549
0
0
Oh God, ten? I'll give it a try...

No particular order other than the number one.
Deus Ex
Red Dead Redemption
Assassin's Creed 2
GTA IV (Yeah, that's right, I actually really liked that game)
Splinter Cell Chaos Theory
Far Cry Instincts
Tony Hawk's Underground (These two= fond childhood memories)
Deus Ex Human Revolution (maybe it's too early considering it hasn't been around too long, but dammit, I LOVED this game. The atmosphere, the art direction, incredible.)
Portal 2
GTA San Andreas
 

Lucky Godzilla

New member
Oct 31, 2012
146
0
0
uh let's see here
MGS3
CoD4
Shadow of the Colossus
Portal
Uncharted 2
Bastion
Spec ops: the Line
Fallout 3
Super Mario galaxy
Metriod prime
 

RedDeadFred

Illusions, Michael!
May 13, 2009
4,896
0
0
I'm only going to pick one game per series:

1. Skyrim
2. Mass Effect 2/3 -I can't decide which game I like more.
3. Borderlands 2
4. Legend of Zelda: the Wind Waker
5. Fallout 3
6. Bastion
7. Minecraft
8. Shining Force
9. LoL
10. Rock Band 2
 

DeltaEdge

New member
May 21, 2010
639
0
0
Fractral said:
Terminate421 said:
Fractral said:
CarolusRex said:
Pokemon: Black 2
You'd put black 2 above the first? I didn't think it was as good. Actually, you're the first person I've seen do that.
TizzytheTormentor said:
1)Final Fantasy IX (My favorite game of all time)
Awesome! Someone else also puts FFIX first on their list. Seems like that game gets forgotten a lot, overlooked in favour of FFVII and FFVIII. Its a shame, too- it has the best characters and story from almost any game.

OT: I don't have 10.
1) Final Fantasy IX
2) Half Life 2
3) Persona 3
4) Sins of A Solar Empire: Trinity (specifically with the Distant Stars mod, but vanilla is epic too)
5) Pokemon White
Actually I would as well.

Pokemon World Tournament is fucking awesome. Also the New Team Plasma is cool.
I couldn't put my finger on it... yeah, World Tournament is awesome, and yeah the new stuff is cool, but it just lacked something for me. It felt kinda empty, really. Like how after you get to undella town nothing really happens for an hour, you just wind your way through to Opelucid city. It was the most boring part of the game for me. I had the same problem with all of HG/SS- the entire of the Kanto area just felt dead to me.
Though that gym leader who seemed to be permanently stoned was epic. And what happens after you beat Drayden- well, I won't spoil it but it was so awesome. I was so shocked at that.
I actually really enjoyed Pokemon Black 2 more than Black 1 as well. Also notable, the Pokemon World Tournament isn't the only thing to do post game. Aside from just level grinding and swapping out party members, there are still plenty of goals to reach post game. You can battle Cynthia at Caitlyn's Villa in Undella town and her Pokemon are in the mid-high 70s range. There is also the Black Tower in Black City, which has 10 areas, and spans in level and challenge from the high 40s to the 80s I believe. I'm on the final floor at the moment, and the Pokemon are all leveled at the high 70s, so the Boss trainer will probably also be in the low-mid 80s. I also think that the AI's have gotten quite good at predicting and strategizing. The enemies in Black tower really do switch their moves accordingly to what Pokemon you are using. (ex. I was battling a lv 77 Zebstrika, and if I was using a Pokemon which it did neutral damage against, it would usually poison me with toxic. If I swapped out to say Bisharp, it would adjust and use flame charge, and used thunderbolt if I swapped into Slowbro. I even did a save-state test to make sure that the comp wasn't just pre-selecting moves while I was in the process of choosing a Pokemon to swap to) Basically, they don't make very many sloppy mistakes, and have become quite efficient at abusing weaknesses. I've been playing for about 15 hours of the Post-game, and am still adequately entertained and finding new areas and things.
Anyways, OP
Pokemon Black 1/2
Tales of the Abyss
Tales of the World Radiant mythology series
Tales of Vesperia
Disgaea series
Minecraft
Sonic Adventure 1 (I hated 2 so much, it isn't even funny)
Persona 3+4
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Kirby Superstar Ultra
[sub]No order to this list as I have a hard time choosing favorites.[/sub]
 

Popbangwoo

New member
Jan 6, 2012
29
0
0
Bearing in mind I am mainly a pc gamer.
1) Command And Conquer: Tiberian Sun
2) Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle Earth
3) Rise of Nations
4) Borderlands 2
5) DOTA 2
6) Portal 2
7) Silent Hill (Original PS1)
8) Far Cry 1 ( When it was actually good, very high hopes for FC3)
9) Assassin's Creed Brotherhood
10) Rollercoaster Tycoon 2

And yes, I do like RTS games ;)

EDIT: Holy crap. Just realised I didn't put KOTOR on here.... DOH
KOTOR would definitely be my number 1.
 

shrekfan246

Not actually a Japanese pop star
May 26, 2011
6,374
0
0
Hm. I'll put these in spoilers, as I'm going to do mini-explanations for my rationalization of each.

[HEADING=1]#10[/HEADING][HEADING=2]Pokemon Gold & Silver/HeartGold & SoulSilver[/HEADING]
When I was a young lad, I got a Gameboy and Pokemon Blue for Christmas one year. It was an experience unlike anything I had had before, and immediately pulled me in, entrancing me in the world of Pokemon and making me wish for more. A few years later, Gold & Silver were released to satiate my desires, and they were the pinnacle, the absolute apex of what I could expect a Pokemon game to deliver. The updated re-releases for the Nintendo DS cashed in on my nostalgia in the best ways, delivering an experience that made me remember why I fell in love with the franchise to begin with while simultaneously making me feel disillusioned with the path that more modern titles were taking in embracing all of the multi-player and tournament things that I had no interest in.

[HEADING=1]#9[/HEADING][HEADING=2]Halo (Franchise)[/HEADING]
I played a few smatterings of first-person shooters while I was growing up - Doom, Wolfenstein, Star Wars: Dark Forces II - but nothing seemed to hit the same level that Halo reached (after all, arguably the most interesting sections of Dark Forces II and its sequel were after you got your lightsaber and started training Force Powers). Massive, sprawling levels, interesting and intelligent enemies that would dynamically react to you, beautiful environments and some of the tightest controls I've ever experienced in a shooter even today, Halo had everything. Well, okay, the first one didn't. But Halo 2 improved on it immensely, adding more weapons, more locations, different play-styles (I'm sure a lot of people won't agree, but the campaign switching between Master Chief and the Arbiter was a great addition in my opinion), and overhauling the combat to take advantage of the new dual-wielding and melee systems that had been implemented. These two games may have also ruined vehicle controls in FPS' for me, as ever since I played 2 I've had a penchant for vehicles that turn along with the camera instead of independently of it, one of my biggest bug-bears with Crysis.

[HEADING=1]#8[/HEADING][HEADING=2]World of Warcraft[/HEADING]
In terms of sheer hours played, WoW beats out every other game I've ever played. In the last five years, I've spent more consistent time with it than any other game, even ones I occasionally return to such as Sonic 3 or Final Fantasy VII-IX. And, despite burning out on it every now and then, I can honestly say that I don't regret any of it. The people I've met, the raiding I've done, the fun I've had is all immeasurable and if I could do it all over again, I wouldn't change a single thing. I continue to play to this day, though with a significantly lower average than I did back when I was in high school, and will continue until it's simply not fun anymore.

[HEADING=1]#7[/HEADING][HEADING=2]Banjo-Tooie[/HEADING]
Now, I feel bad about putting this one so low on the list as it's basically what I hold up to be the perfect example of how to make a 3D Platformer. It took everything set up in Banjo-Kazooie and made it bigger and better. The controls were smoother, the world was much more tightly-crafted and well-knit together, the story was still light and amusing while carrying even more heavy undertones, and the moveset expanded to allow so many new things that it truly felt like a title worthy of being called a sequel. It surpassed the first game on so many levels, it is paramount in any explanation of how games were created over a decade ago. The sprawling world and inter-connected levels really gave a feeling of context that was lacking from Banjo-Kazooie, and the way it mixed up the formula always kept it from going stale. Truly an excellent game.

[HEADING=1]#6[/HEADING][HEADING=2]Kingdom Hearts II[/HEADING]
Oh boy, Kingdom Hearts. I've got a rather love-hate relationship going on with that franchise right now. On the one hand, I love it so much. The story, the characters, the worlds, the music, the gameplay, everything about it draws me in and makes me want more. On the other hand... Squeenix, why do you have to release side-stories on every single handheld imaginable, and never compile any of them onto one system? But, this isn't about that.

Kingdom Hearts was basically my introduction to action-RPGs. Disney and Final Fantasy all in one? Yes, please! And so when Kingdom Hearts II came out, I just knew that I needed it. And it didn't disappoint. After the relatively slow start where we're introduced to Roxas, the game really just opens up. The combat feels faster, the new Reaction Commands, while functionally just quick-time events, really felt like they added a new dimension to fighting enemies, and it was all just so well-rounded and, well, epic. The story felt more mature, and it never slacked for a second. I mean, I won't hold up the franchise as an example of how you should write a story, but it still managed to create touching stories with a rather large ensemble cast of characters, with many of the talented voice actors who had portrayed Disney characters in the past returning to recoup their roles. And the entire time it felt like it was constantly building up to something bigger, something larger that tied the entire series together and... well, the payoff in the end wasn't as definitive as it could have been and the franchise has largely been on ice since.

[HEADING=1]#5[/HEADING][HEADING=2]Metal Gear Solid 3: Subsistence[/HEADING]
Metal Gear Solid is the franchise that got me into stealth games. Without it, I probably never would've played Deus Ex: Human Revolution, or Mark of the Ninja, or Assassin's Creed, or, hell, even Dishonored. I've never really attempted to try the Thief games and the style of Hitman was never appealing to me, but something about MGS just... clicked with me.

3 is plagued by the same issues that the entire franchise has; Namely, it could really use a damn editor to cut down all of the exposition. But the campy nature of the story, the absolutely fantastic stealthy-gunplay (and a camera that's been vastly improved over 2 and the original release of 3), the pseudo-industrial forest environments, and some of the best characterization and Easter Eggs I've ever seen in a game all combine to make it a wonderful experience that I'm glad I've had. It's also got one of the most fantastic and heart-wrenching final boss-fights that I've seen.

[HEADING=1]#4[/HEADING][HEADING=2]Sonic Generations[/HEADING]
Now, if you wanted me to be completely honest, I'm not sure if I'd say Generations is my favorite Sonic game. But in terms of what it's accomplished, reconciling the old style of Sonic gameplay and finally making it work with the more modern gameplay, I have to admire it more than any other Sonic title. My issues with it stem almost completely from the fact that it's basically just an Anniversary Collection, stitching together levels from all of the past Sonic games in the "main" continuity and slapping a haphazard story to tie it all together. Though Sonic works best when he's got a minimalistic story, the levels seeming to have a context in between them always makes the game "gel" together much more effectively, which is something that Generations lacks. Setting all of that aside though, everything else about it just seems to work, which is something that had been lacking from every game in between Sonic Adventure 2 (which itself had those weird Mech Levels inspired by E-102 from Adventure) and Sonic Colors.

Modern Sonic's controls are so tight that it's almost difficult to remember that this is the same character who was the player-character in Sonic '06, and while Classic Sonic's jump always feels a bit shorter than the old days, it's still frighteningly reminiscent of that good old Sonic feel 2 and 3 always gave me. The music contains lively remixes of old tracks. Green Hill Zone, Chemical Plant Zone, Sky Sanctuary, they've all got remixes that bring back the nostalgia with a fresh coat of paint, and just for good measure a lot of tracks from older (and more obscure) Sonic games have been included as unlockable content, free to use instead of a level's base music once you've unlocked it.

To put it simply, Generations is more than just a good Sonic game - It's a good game, period.

[HEADING=1]#3[/HEADING][HEADING=2]Mass Effect (Franchise)[/HEADING]
It's not often that I replay long games. It's even less often that I replay long games and the rest of their franchises, which are also long games. And yet the fact remains that I've played through the entire franchise completely, twice (and a half, really), and have started working on a third play-through. I'm not sure what it is about Mass Effect that keeps me wanting to play it again. The characters have endeared themselves to me, and I always want to see how differently certain situations could play out depending on whether I'm a Renegade or Paragon, and not to mention the different styles of actual gameplay the different classes can adopt. While it all falls back on the basic shooting mechanics eventually, playing through as a Soldier is vastly different from playing as an Adept, and both are significantly different than playing a Vanguard. It all helps keep the games from feeling stale, and can contribute greatly to actually role-playing as Shepard.

Mass Effect provides me with a singularly unique experience: Never before have I seen what is essentially a single game spanning three titles that actually takes a person's personal canon into account at the beginning of each new title. Every time I do something differently in the first game, or complete more of the side-missions, I find new and different Easter Eggs in the second after importing my save. And it's little things like that which keep me coming back.

[HEADING=1]#2[/HEADING][HEADING=2]Okami[/HEADING]
Okami is more than a game. It's something truly beautiful. It's something that I can't rationally compare to anything else. I picked it up on a whim after I had gotten a PS2 and when I played it, I was just astonished. At the time, I never really drew the parallels between it and The Legend of Zelda even though I had played a fair few titles in the latter franchise, because it just felt so new. It's a gorgeous game, with a gorgeous soundtrack, and it practically oozes atmosphere. The only thing that makes me sad about it is that it only sold 600,000 copies between the PS2 and Wii versions. (Well, okay, I've got a few issues with it like the incredibly slow scrolling speed of the opening text and other plot-relevant text that you can't skip through or speed up, but that really does fade into the background once you actually get to play the game.)

I may never be able to say enough to give proper justice to this title, but I'll sure as hell try.

So what's my number 1, you might be asking? I've already picked Okami, what else could possibly fill the void? Well, ask and you shall receive.

[HEADING=1]#1[/HEADING][HEADING=2]Final Fantasy IX[/HEADING]
Final Fantasy and I have a rather long history. VII was the first RPG I ever played (excluding Pokemon), and it began a long-running love of the franchise that has led to... a fairly turbulent past few years. I've played through every main-series installment since VII (and a few of the spin-offs), and I've tried pushing my way through the older titles, but to this day nothing surpasses the crowning achievement that is Final Fantasy IX.

It still has all of the staples you'd come to expect from a Final Fantasy game - Fairly linear progression through the first few hours of the game, an absurd plot with hammy and campy writing, twists from out of nowhere even before the actual thrust of the story starts winding up, and an androgynous male main character. But even with all of that, it manages to elevate itself above the groundwork laid down by the previous games. The characters are well-realized, the twists are poignant and meaningful, arcs actually feel like they have weight because we've seen these characters exhibit actual emotion as we've been following them, and certain elements of the plot (which I won't spoil) actually have tangible effects on the active gameplay as you proceed through the discs, which is something that I had never seen before and have rarely seen implemented well ever since.

As well, the musical score is just fantastic. While there isn't any singular iconic track like "One-Winged Angel", the entire soundtrack just feels like it's some of composer Uematsu's best work. They compliment the environments you're traveling through in a way that even Final Fantasy VII could rarely accomplish. And as for the environments... well, they're fantastic. While the previous two games had adopted a pseudo-realistic post-modern industrial-fantasy world (that's a lot of describing words there), IX elected to go for a simpler, steampunk-inspired world, and it does the setting a lot of favors in terms of getting away with crazy things. The world has a rather grandiose scale, as well, which you don't discover until quite a few hours in. Initially you get tricked, as your world map only shows you the continent that you begin on and by about 6-8 hours in you feel like you've seen most of what that continent might have to offer, but then it opens up and you realize that there's another three continents that you haven't explored yet.

The game is jam-packed with little extras, as well, ranging from the reintroduction of Moogles and the "class" system to a weapon that you can only obtain if you reach one of the final areas of the game within 12 hours of playtime. But most importantly, it felt like a Final Fantasy game. There was exploration, there were people to pointlessly talk to, there was a lot of silly dialogue used just to give the characters a more human appearance, there was equipment and inventory management, there were shops, there were mini-games and side-quests, and there was the fanfare.
 

CarolusRex

New member
Jan 20, 2012
42
0
0
Fractral said:
You'd put black 2 above the first? I didn't think it was as good. Actually, you're the first person I've seen do that.
I liked Black. Definitely one of my favourite Pokemon games, but for some reason I just found Black 2 more fun. Might of been everything extra that they added into it, like the PWT. I love the idea of the old champions, gym leaders etc being brought back.
 

42Weasels

New member
Oct 26, 2012
22
0
0
In no real order,

-The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
-The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
-Final Fantasy Tactics: War of the Lions (because if I take it off the list the 150 or so DAYS I spent playing it are officially wasted)
-Fallout: New Vegas
-Tetris
-Minecraft
-League of Legends and Dota 2 (I love you both equally, even though you don't get along)
-Borderlands 1 (Borderlands 2 will likely replace this one, once I've finished it)
-Pokemon Emerald
-Kirby and the Amazing Mirror
 

DrunkOnEstus

In the name of Harman...
May 11, 2012
1,712
0
0
ohnoitsabear said:
IVAN (an excellent free rougelike)
Thank you so much for mentioning this. I went and downloaded it immediately after reading, and it's such an awesome middle ground between ASCII and something like Binding of Issac. The more roguelikes, the better.