Why would you want to ask a games developer? I thought we wanted an objective review! When you ask the developer what they intended you are going to pick up their biases. And they will obviously tell you what they want you to put in your review. People would complain that the reviewer is corrupt, and selling the developers line. For petes sake, half the internet is on fire over this (remember, its about ethics in video game journalism)Thanatos2k said:It really isn't though, because it's very clear that it was also the intent of the developers that the game is not about the core cover-based-shooter gameplay.
I mean, if you wanted to be sure, you could ask the developers if that was the case. I'm sure they'd be happy to confirm it. (You're a professional, right? Not above asking the source?)
Figuring out "What the developers intended" is a huge part of being a professional reviewer, and in the parts of your review that are subjective you should be focusing a lot on whether they were successful or not.
Yes, figuring out what the developer intended is part of being a reviewer. Its also completely subjective. Whether they got the message across or actually made a good game worth playing is completely based on your own opinion, your own subjectivity. I can read the statistics for the game from the back of the box. I want to know if its enjoyable. And finding a selection of reviewers with similar/differing opinions and checking my own biases against them will tell me if I will enjoy that game.