Terramax said:
Andy of Comix Inc said:
Terramax said:
Yep, I figured this would be like every Suda 51 game I've come across - overrated.
You mean overhyped? I can't think of any overrated Suda51 game. Most of them fall into "cult classic" territory, and if you think that means "overrated" then you're on a high horse so high it's gone up your arsehole.
Oh, you sound so sexy when you're angry.
No, I mean overrated. Many of their games have received great acclaim critically.
Suda51 is a single man. Not a company. But that's besides the point.
Let's go by Metacritic: his games have, in order of release, gained a 70/100 (
Killer 7), 83/100 (
No More Heroes), 84/100 (
No More Heroes 2), 76/100 (
Shadows of the Damned), 72/100 (
No More Heroes for PS3), and now 69/100 (
Lollipop Chainsaw). Mixed and positive all across the board, a handful of negative. You think that's "overrated"? Or realistic?
Like I said - most of his popularity comes from his cult following.
Fans love his games. And if you think fans liking games constitutes overrated, then, you're dumb.
I'm not
angry, I'm just confused why Suda51's games' popularity can be attributed to anything BUT cult followings.
GTAIV is overrated. The
Halo series is overrated. Suda51's games? They're pretty realistically rated. Fans are audacious, and some fans are reviewers, but for the most part, people are damn fair on these games. If you honestly think reviewers are being blinded by fanboyism (or whatever) you're WRONG. I mean you're commenting on a THREE STAR REVIEW. Arguing the games are OVER-RATED. An average-playing game got an average score!
IT MUST BE OVERRATED!
Suda51 is on the
fringe of popularity. Honestly, he's as popular as he deserves. People understand that he's a better writer than he is a gameplay designer. People understand that it is his sense of humour that makes him, not his directorial capacity. "Overrated" is an overstatement. People enjoy his games, and respect his games, for reasons like "good sense of humour" and "attempting something unique". They are judged as wholes, as a whole, on their own merits, and get the scores overall they deserve.
Thee stars. "Overrated." Bah.