viranimus said:
That's all fine and dandy, but LulzSec isn't doing this as some sort of crusade for freedom. If anything, this will make lawmakers more scared of the Internet and many who would have ignored the problem before will now call out for regulation. They fully realize that, and yet they don't care. They're doing it anyway.
They're just doing this because they can. They are pointing out the holes in the security of these organizations. So put a hold on your Ben Franklin quotes and just think about the consequences of this for a minute--not just for them, but for everyone.
First, investigations and lawsuits will put Sony into further financial distress. It could very well get to a point where they have to start letting people go while they lick their legal and financial wounds. The suits and trials resulting from all this could go on for years.
And I'm not saying Sony doesn't deserve it. If what they said about Sony's security was true (because at this point, all of the news regarding this has come from LulzSec itself. Sony has confirmed nothing), then I think they do deserve to have a cigarette or two put out in their eye. Treating such valuable information so flippantly is inexcusable.
As for the FBI and NATO, it's the same thing. They're doing it because they can. They brought down that little outlet FBI web site and compromised their information just to prove they could do it. And they are using the knowledge that they've informed the FBI of their (apparently) lackluster security as a way of legitimizing their actions.
But here's the thing: If you break into someone's house and steal their TV, the law doesn't care why you stole the TV. They don't care if you stole it for shits and giggles or so you could sell it to feed your starving children. The fact is you stole a TV. Why you stole it does not make it any more right or wrong in the eyes of the law.
The same goes with them. Who cares why they're doing it? The fact is they are committing acts of cyberterrorism and (if they are American) treason, and the repercussions from what they've done will continue to negatively affect people for quite a long time. What LulzSec is doing will not cause any improvements in the field of Internet and Information freedom. If anything, their actions will bring us closer to China's way of running the Internet.
I'm not saying it's a battle that doesn't need to be fought. I'm simply saying they have chosen both the wrong people to fight and the wrong way of fighting.