Well, seeing as we live in the universe where she said yes and got shot, we can't really say with any certainty that her saying no would have saved her life. Saying yes could be the reason she got shot, maybe Klebold would have shot her anyway. If it even was her that was asked the question.DementedSheep said:That's what I meant sorry. I can see how that sentence was confusing. The song makes it sound like saying yes is why she got shot. There is time for standing up for what you believe in and making a statement but this was not ongoing oppression of a group or trying to keep beliefs silent, it is a couple of students going off. You're not doing anything by declaring yes rather than lying and saying no other than throwing your life away.Techno Squidgy said:That's not how I interpreted the song at all. The way I heard it, it sounded as though the singer was saying she would also answer yes in the same circumstances.DementedSheep said:Yeah I heard, it's one of the reason I don't like the song. It paints her saying yes knowing he would shoot her as a good thing and that the singer would do the same.Techno Squidgy said:If I recall correctly, this is a reference to the Columbine High School massacre. A girl was hiding under a desk, one of the shooters found her and knowing she was religious this exchange happened.DementedSheep said:I probably shouldn't say this one cause it's tied in with religion but Cassie by Flyleaf. Most song can have horrible lyrics and I won't really care but with that one the subject matter and the lyrics are enough to put me off because I see it as a pointless waste of life rather than a good thing.
"Do you believe in God?"
Written on the bullet
Say "Yes" to pull the trigger
"Do you believe in God?"
Written on the bullet
And Cassie pulled the trigger"
Though there's some debate as to whether the exchange actually took place, or if it was even Cassie Bernal that this happened too.
I haven't read up on this subject in a while though, so I might have a few details wrong.
I'm not religious myself, but I bet many would rather die than denounce their faith. After all, they believe their god is constantly watching and judging them, right? If they believed they were about to die regardless, why denounce their faith right before they meet their maker?