Fox12 said:
Taylor Swifts "Love Story." I can forgive bad writing as the product of a feeble mind, but this jumbled up amalgamated mess of failed symbolism and references made me physically ill.
"Cause you were Romeo, I was a scarlet letter
And my daddy said stay away from Juliet
But you were everything to me
I was begging you please don't go and I said
Romeo take me somewhere we can be alone
I'll be waiting all there's left to do is run
You'll be the prince and I'll be the princess
It's a love story baby just say yes."
...what? Romeo and Juliet wasn't a love story, it was a tragedy about two sixteen year old dipshits who got married after one day. Then everyone died. It wasn't supposed to be romantic. The Scarlet Letter was about a woman who was abandoned by her husband, so she had an affair, and got pregnant out of wedlock. Then she was ostracized by society. What does any of this have to do with anything? Did Taylor run off with another guy after knowing him for one day, then get pregnant with his baby, so everyone hated her? That's how it sounds. I don't think that's whay she was going for. It's sick... she just, she just says words, and they don't mean anything. It's like explosive diarrhea of the mouth. Does she even think about any of the things she writes, or does she jut list thing she's vaguely heard of before? I'm feeling ill, I need to lay down.
This is pretty funny though.
http://bigenoughumbrella.tumblr.com/post/15352556534/t-swizzle-and-the-scarlet-letter-an-overanalysis-of
I'm not sure how you can deny that the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet contains a love story. In fact, it is widely considered
the love story. It's about two people who are so in love that they go against their families' wishes to be together, get married within one day and don't want to live in a world without the other. You can think that's stupid, but clearly there is a love story in there.
I don't really know much about the scarlet letter, but I'm pretty sure she's referring to the ostracization she is or would be facing. Or at least, that's what she's afraid off. In the end it obviously turns out fine though, because her guy talks to her dad who unlike Capulet is 100% fine with their relationship.
I don't think she's trying to accurately tell the tale of Romeo and Juliet (or any other known literary work for that matter). Rather, I think the correct interpretation here is that a teenage girl who is giving her perspective on an early romance and drawing parallels with some stories she knows (and may or may not have interpreted naively on account of being a teenager). I think the "real" story is that she liked some boy when she was young and her father/parents disapproved (likely because of her age) (there are some really obvious parallels to R+J here). I don't know why she would feel "ostracized" (for the scarlet letter part), but it could be anything from her feeling awkward/insecure/unpopular to her family disapproving of sneaking around with her boyfriend in "secret". Then for whatever reason her family came around (possibly because the boyfriend actually went to talk to them and show he's a decent guy) and they could live happily ever after as prince and princess in their fantasy love story. (Although knowing some other songs, they likely broke up immediately so Taylor could date 100 other guys to write songs about.)