If you think about it, it's actually not too disturbing. Everything on that server is the collective work of many, many, many people. Not saying that what they've achieved is any less grand...
True enough. I would have filled the bottom with obsidian to just make it look like a black hole from the height of the bridge. I think I am done niggling about this, though.Fiad said:They are working with the limits of Minecraft, they most likely hit bedrock right there and couldn't make the bottomless pit without opening up the void which would just be a bright blue area, which would just look odd.samsonguy920 said:Something I just doublechecked as well, but on the Bridge where Gandalf confronted the Balrog, it spanned an empty and very deep chasm. There were no flames or lava below. These people need to proofread themselves. (The flames and lava were in a crack further back in the chamber that the Balrog leapt over.)
If it were truly based on Minecraft they would have broken through to the Nether and ended up with a gross of Ghasts.thaluikhain said:...Le Snip
You mean the makers of Moria weren't able to delve too deep? Probably a good thing, really.
They mention in the video that the world is detailed from the descriptions in Tolkien's books, and I believe some of the games as well. Not the movies. It was just their choice I guess.samsonguy920 said:They aren't even close to where things start going wonky. However if they did do 1:1 ratio for distance, they would probably hit wonkyville at about Minas Tirith. But that's just a rough guess.Scizophrenic Llama said:This is Minecraft, though. An hour travel distance is considered a ludicrous amount. They want to expand it, but they've hit the limit for map generation. Apparently after so far the random generation starts getting extremely odd, so Notch slapped on a limit.Valate said:That's still much smaller than you're making it sound. Rivendell is roughly a weeks travel from Bree, even Weathertop is a good 48 hour hike. The Mines of Moria? That's a good month long journey from Bree. So I'll say it's pretty huge, but nothing absolutely mind blowing.
I want a download of the map. D:
Something I just doublechecked as well, but on the Bridge where Gandalf confronted the Balrog, it spanned an empty and very deep chasm. There were no flames or lava below. These people need to proofread themselves. (The flames and lava were in a crack further back in the chamber that the Balrog leapt over.)
Hmm... Maybe if you send them a message they will consider incorporating your Helm's Deep in the server? I assume they have theirs made already, but if yours is better I could see them changing them out (Minecraft editors ftw).Cpt Corallis said:AWWWW COME ON! I literally just finished building my scale model of Helm's Deep a week ago. And then they go and do this?!
I wish I could say not cool, but this is too awesome for me to be bitter.This is pretty much the same response I got when I showed my friends Helm's deep.Andy Chalk said:"You guys are sick," the host said. "You need help."
I didn't mention the movies. The movies have too many miscrepancies to be proper references. I grew up reading the books from cover to cover. However, the movie Fellowship of the Ring was actually faithful to the novel as regards to the chamber containing the Bridge of Khazad-dum.Burningsok said:They mention in the video that the world is detailed from the descriptions in Tolkien's books, and I believe some of the games as well. Not the movies. It was just their choice I guess.samsonguy920 said:They aren't even close to where things start going wonky. However if they did do 1:1 ratio for distance, they would probably hit wonkyville at about Minas Tirith. But that's just a rough guess.Scizophrenic Llama said:This is Minecraft, though. An hour travel distance is considered a ludicrous amount. They want to expand it, but they've hit the limit for map generation. Apparently after so far the random generation starts getting extremely odd, so Notch slapped on a limit.Valate said:That's still much smaller than you're making it sound. Rivendell is roughly a weeks travel from Bree, even Weathertop is a good 48 hour hike. The Mines of Moria? That's a good month long journey from Bree. So I'll say it's pretty huge, but nothing absolutely mind blowing.
I want a download of the map. D:
Something I just doublechecked as well, but on the Bridge where Gandalf confronted the Balrog, it spanned an empty and very deep chasm. There were no flames or lava below. These people need to proofread themselves. (The flames and lava were in a crack further back in the chamber that the Balrog leapt over.)