Minecraft yay or nay?!

Recommended Videos

TheYellowCellPhone

New member
Sep 26, 2009
8,613
0
0
Mazty said:
TheYellowCellPhone said:
Mazty said:
Its free for students to download, not limited to your class.
So the construction part of Minecraft isn't a game then?
So then shouldn't those people move on to Blender or 3DS Max?
I've been staring at this post for a bit now and I'm wondering where you pulled that idea out of...
The only game part about MC is the killing monsters as the buildings serve no purpose.
Curious, you could use that argument for any game. I can do this too... "look at Morrowind, all you do is kill monsters and walk in forests. It's so useless and serves no purpose!"

If you play it for the construction, well if you think 3DS max isn't a game, why is MC if you play it just for the purpose of construction?
Because there's more to Minecraft than construction. You said so yourself, there's monsters in it, does 3DS Max have monsters? What about water, lava, natural cave systems, crafting, etc.?

If you want to make shit and walk about it, Blender/3DS Max + Morrowind is infinitely better and cheaper. MC is just terrible.
Again, you stand in the shelter of your 3D editing programs and Morrowind. How predictable.

Before I leave and add you to my ignore list, realize this: Not everyone plays it just for construction. I play it for the struggle of survival, the mining, the exploration, the building of inventions using redstone and water. The construction I just barely use, only for making a base the first two nights. I'd like to see your precious 3d software do that.

And maybe people enjoy gathering materials for construction, or being able to walk through their buildings. If they want instant and sure, better looking structures, then they can get your precious 3D software.

You're not worth my time. Does it not concern you just how many people disagree with this randomass comparison of Minecraft to 3DS Max? Think about this, when's the last time someone changed your opinion on anything? I certainly hope you didn't have to think for that long to think of something.
 

StraightToHeck

Booby booby bum bum.
Oct 13, 2010
264
0
0
it's very fun as long as you have something to build; creativity and imagination are crucial to the enjoyment of this game

plus it's a one-time charge and not a subscription, so.......
 

spartandude

New member
Nov 24, 2009
2,721
0
0
Nay, its creative i guess but theres no use to the creations and the world just feels so empty

YAY! i created an entire city.... and im the only one in it
 

Raikazu

New member
Apr 15, 2009
116
0
0
Minecraft is a game I enjoy in small doses. I've created complex underground caverns, build castles, trailed around miles and miles of the map and at the end of it all you can just lose motivation when it boasts no rewards.

It's a good timesink.
 

StormShaun

The Basement has been unleashed!
Feb 1, 2009
6,947
0
0
If you feel like Lego but on a computer play it...

If I wanted to have fun with physics, G-MOD...