Most Under-rated Game

Blair Bennett

New member
Jan 25, 2008
595
0
0
Julianking93 said:
Nier. No question.

Got decent to poor reviews by most critics yet it was my favourite game of last year and the best game I had played in a while. Amazing game which proves most critics are superficial assholes who can't appreciate a good game despite minor flaws.
Fuck you, Gamespot and IGN.
Fuck you hard.
I was ready to come in here, guns a'blazin', and convince people that Nier is awesome, and it appears you've beat me to it. Yeah, the combat was sort of unimaginative, but this game had me dangerously close to tears at points, and that is something that I pride myself on making quite difficult. Nier was refreshing, and it pains me that it doesn't really get the credit for it. Also, axe crazy Laura Bailey is one of the most entertaining things Earth has to offer, and a lot of people missed out on that because it got lukewarm reviews when it deserved better.
 

Chibz

New member
Sep 12, 2008
2,158
0
0
CrashTestZombie said:
+1 vote for Deadly Premonition. Anyone who loved Twin Peaks or Case Closed should give this game a try. It can be dull at times, but the story was worth it.
Not to mention it's also a very inexpensive game! My BF's copy was $18, NEW. What's Twin Peak? I've heard of it, but never played it before.

Most the games on my list are worth a play through. However, most people on the forums haven't heard of most of them. Excepting Startropics, Legend of Zelda 2, and Mystic Quest...
 

Flutterguy

New member
Jun 26, 2011
970
0
0
I know alot of friends did not like Tale Concerto (my favourite game of the generation), also Timesplitters series. Yet since time has moved on and I have looked up these games online they have mostly positive reviews. I usually do no buy games that are given bad reviews as I work hard for my money and hate burning it in a fire of 1 hour of gameplay till ragequit.
 

Chibz

New member
Sep 12, 2008
2,158
0
0
Flutterguy said:
I usually do no buy games that are given bad reviews as I work hard for my money and hate burning it in a fire of 1 hour of gameplay till ragequit.
Reviewers are an overall terrible way to determine the relative quality of a game. On gamerankings FF12 got a 90.64 rating. Phantom Brave: We Meet Again got a 76.73. What the hell?
 

Flutterguy

New member
Jun 26, 2011
970
0
0
Chibz said:
Flutterguy said:
I usually do no buy games that are given bad reviews as I work hard for my money and hate burning it in a fire of 1 hour of gameplay till ragequit.
Reviewers are an overall terrible way to determine the relative quality of a game. On gamerankings FF12 got a 90.64 rating. Phantom Brave: We Meet Again got a 76.73. What the hell?
I don't really see why you can be mad at a review of any new FF games, or any series of such magnitude (CoD, Street Fighter etc.), by this point most gamers should know whether or not they will be buying it without a reviewers help.
 

thethingthatlurks

New member
Feb 16, 2010
2,102
0
0
Julianking93 said:
Nier. No question.

Got decent to poor reviews by most critics yet it was my favourite game of last year and the best game I had played in a while. Amazing game which proves most critics are superficial assholes who can't appreciate a good game despite minor flaws.
Fuck you, Gamespot and IGN.
Fuck you hard.
So very true. It's still one of my most played games, despite some flaws. The "adventure" level might fit somewhat, but it's annoying and quite out of place, and the fishing really needs a proper tutorial. Oh, and the magic attacks are quite stupidly overpowered. For anybody wondering what Yahtzee was referring to in his review, it's a spell called "dark lance," which in terms of balance is equivalent to bringing a tank with bullet time to a plastic knife fight. Otherwise, it's a great game!
 

Chibz

New member
Sep 12, 2008
2,158
0
0
Flutterguy said:
I don't really see why you can be mad at a review of any new FF games, or any series of such magnitude (CoD, Street Fighter etc.), by this point most gamers should know whether or not they will be buying it without a reviewers help.
I'm less mad and more ... frustrated that we cannot depend on game reviewers to provide an insightful, unbiased opinion on games anymore. FF12 certainly didn't deserve that 90.something score. Phantom Brave certainly deserves a higher score overall. It's maddening.
 

neonsword13-ops

~ Struck by a Smooth Criminal ~
Mar 28, 2011
2,771
0
0
Psychonauts.
Brutal Legend.
Monster Hunter Tri.
Resonance of Fate.
All I can put at the top of my head.
 

Crazedc00k

New member
Mar 29, 2011
66
0
0
The Mount and Blade series has received no attention for its outstanding mod system and friendliness. Thats like eating the cone and not the ice cream.
 

creonto

New member
Feb 16, 2011
44
0
0
Jegsimmons said:
HALO 1...no seriously, alot of people wont bother with it even though it made FPSs what they are today and pretty muched saved the xbox.
I couldn't agree more. Halo 1 is the game that introduced me to gaming roughly eight years ago and i have been an avid gamer ever since, regardless of the fact that i spent the second half of it scared out of my mind of the flood.
 

Couch Radish

New member
Mar 28, 2011
180
0
0
Definitely Saint's Row 2. Almost everyone I know only knows of Grand Theft Auto.

I tell them SR2 is better than GTA4 but they never listen.
 

Soxafloppin

Coxa no longer floppin'
Jun 22, 2009
7,918
0
0
Cell Damage! Great party game! Lots of fun to be had with Local multiplayer!

Lost Kingdoms 1 and 2: Real time, monster summoning card battles with a decent story and neat setting, if you like collecting things you will like these games, oh and there playable on Wii since they were Gamecube games, so yea. Pick these up!
 

Mr.Swiggly

The PC Master Elitist
Apr 25, 2011
32
0
0
Age of Empires 3

Alot of people, including reviewers, think that it is the weakest of the Age of Empires series, but it was the funnest one that I've played, and the amount of customization for each faction is mind-blowing.It is also the fastest paced one in the series, and I enjoy faster RTS that dont take me three hours to complete one mission.
 

Soxafloppin

Coxa no longer floppin'
Jun 22, 2009
7,918
0
0
Cell Damage! Great party game! Lots of fun to be had with Local multiplayer!

Lost Kingdoms 1 and 2: Real time, monster summoning card battles with a decent story and neat setting, if you like collecting things you will like these games, oh and there playable on Wii since they were Gamecube games, so yea. Pick these up![/quote]

Mallefunction said:
Sly Cooper is HORRIBLY underrated. :)
This 1000 times!, I jumped on the Sly Wagon pretty late, with the Collection for PS3, but wow did I have fun with those games. I know patiently await Sly 4.
 

Kagobin

New member
Apr 21, 2011
64
0
0
Liberty City Stories for the PS2. Bloody amazing, terribly underrated.


Captcha: hatalre upon
 

Ninjat_126

New member
Nov 19, 2010
775
0
0
Possibly Doom 3. Sure, it tried to be survival horror when it didn't need to be, but the game itself was solid enough and wasn't too bad. If it wasn't called "Doom 3", it might have been better received.
 

6_Qubed

New member
Mar 19, 2009
481
0
0
God Hand.

Yes, I know that it had that one MS Paint comic so technically everyone knows it's good, but nobody I've met ever knows what I'm talking about when I mention it, and then all I can tell them is that it's the best game about punching people that was ever made. Then they look at me funny and slowly back away. :(
 

RoyalSorceress

New member
Jun 15, 2010
204
0
0
One Piece: Unlimited Adventure. If the 3DS version of Unlimited Cruise doesn't come out in America I will be depressed.

Also anything by Level-5, seriously I've never played a Level-5 game that I haven't loved to death. It makes me want to try their upcoming Gundam game and wish that the game they made with Studio Ghibi would come out in America.
 

MortalForNow

New member
Jan 10, 2010
258
0
0
Soxafloppin said:
Mallefunction said:
Sly Cooper is HORRIBLY underrated. :)
This 1000 times!, I jumped on the Sly Wagon pretty late, with the Collection for PS3, but wow did I have fun with those games. I know patiently await Sly 4.
Grew up playing the Sly Cooper games on a recommendation from a friend. That friend also wisely made me aware of the Jak and Daxter series, another greatly underrated series. Interestingly enough, the developers of both series are finding new successes with the inFamous and Uncharted series on the PS3, respectively, right now.

For a critically underrated game? I feel that, while the reception was a major difference between the two, Skate 3 was a vast improvement on the second despite getting the shorter end of the stick. Yes, the tricks stayed the same, but the change from a darker graphics filter (which did not help with my awful standard definition TV) to a brighter one definitely helped and I found the learning curve to be much more forgiving in the third installment, but that may be attributed to my evolution from a terrible Skate player to a more rounded player by the time it came out.

Also, I found the criticism for Guitar Hero: Warriors of Rock to be a bit mean-spirited. In my opinion, the developers tried their best to work themselves out of the pit dug when World Tour (my least favorite of the series) came out and mostly succeeded. The difficulty curve spiked at the end and it was somewhat uninspired, but it was a fun, polished game to play for a while before I moved onto Rock Band 3, which it had the misfortune of competing with at that time. Plus, I loved the 2112 section of the game, which made me filled with with joy over the amount of much-deserved attention Rush was getting in a video game.