What's with all the Soul Eater put-downs lately? Eh, whatever.
Anyway, Evangelion, definitely. Incredibly preachy, especially on the last two episodes (and "the budget ran out" is NOT an acceptable excuse in my book, btw), with bull philosophies that are numbed into your brain.
s-CRY-ed, too. First off all, how are you supposed to say the name of the show. And while it's cool that they can use the material around them to make cybernetic gauntlets, it grates me that you can use pretty much anything to use your "alter powers". At least Fullmetal Alchemist explains that you can only make something out of something else with the same composition. Also, the acting was incredibly monotone and repetitive.
And also, Revolutionary Girl Utena. I understand that it's deep. I understand it explores classic fairy tale tropes, gay attraction, corruption, and even incest. Those parts work pretty well. But having to watch Utena ascend to that stage beneath the Rose Castle got REALLY old, and the fights weren't diverse enough for me at the time I watched (which was, admittedly, four years ago). But I think what really put me off was actually the English dub. The English dub for Utena is, in my opinion, one of the WORST anime dubs I've ever listened to first-hand. And I endured 4Kids One Piece up until Crocodile's defeat. (Didn't really get into One Piece, btw, but I'm not saying it's overrated.) I mean, I think Crispin Freeman was like the only one in the cast even close to trying. Even Rachel Lillis (who's alright otherwise) sounded bored.