No, BioShock Infinite's Ending Doesn't Suck

[1337mokro]

snip

I stopped caring about this 2 days ago.

You won't be able to light the spark again when the only thing you repeatedly give me is speculation and conjecture. It's to bad you weren't around oh.... 15 posts ago because the same questions got asked then. Which means you could have just replied to those and not spent several posts dancing around the issue and eventually still giving me the same thing the other guy was giving me.

Unsubstantiated speculation and conjecture. Something that only serves to highlight the flaws in a story when the motivations are so unclear (by virtue of never being explained) people have to make them up for the game.

Anyway, beyond caring about Bioshock Infinite now. See you when Bioshock Revengeance gets released.

 

[chikusho]

snip

I stopped caring about this 2 days ago.

You won't be able to light the spark again when the only thing you repeatedly give me is speculation and conjecture. It's to bad you weren't around oh.... 15 posts ago because the same questions got asked then. Which means you could have just replied to those and not spent several posts dancing around the issue and eventually still giving me the same thing the other guy was giving me.

Unsubstantiated speculation and conjecture. Something that only serves to highlight the flaws in a story when the motivations are so unclear (by virtue of never being explained) people have to make them up for the game.

Anyway, beyond caring about Bioshock Infinite now. See you when Bioshock Revengeance gets released.

All I'm giving you are deductions from the information the game and its story is giving me which points towards the answer to your questions. Things that I never really perceived as very complicated, but there you have it.
The author and creator of any character will always have more information about the "truth", and then use that truth to decide which actions the character would take. But once released, the character will take on a life on its own amongst the readers, viewers or players where he is judged without being told what to think. This is where the depth truly lies.

Good to know, see you then!

 

[Dunhart]

The only problem I had with Bioshock Infinite's ending was that it was... quite grim. The game had a downer ending steeped in metaphors just for the sake of it. I mean, she's got mastery over time and space, I'm sure she could have thought at least a dozen solutions other than drowning the man.