You've taken all the justification and examples I gave and just said "no it's not". ****** does not just mean gay anymore, is it really that hard to understand? Louis CK does an entire skit about it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fcja4WFFzDwGuestyman said:****** is a great way to cause offence because it's *Offensive*! Jesus Christ is that really so hard to get? When you use ****** you are not using a synonym for "bad". You are using a synonym for homosexual. You are attacking something unchangeable about me in order to make me feel bad, or you are playing on the cultural bullshit attached to straight people in order to make them feel bad because you are implying that THEY ARE LIKE ME. What about that is unclear? "******" isn't a harmless generic insult, it is a targeted slur that is deliberately designed to make me and people like me feel bad SPECIFICALLY.secretsantaone said:If you play a videogame with someone, they don't know your sexuality. Hell, if you don't use voice chat online they don't even know your gender.
However, if you play in such a competitive and immature environment such as XBL, people are going to call you bad words. It really doesn't matter what you are, they'll find some way to offend you and make it stick. The same way that people will say they slept with your mother last night, of course they fucking didn't, but people get defensive of their mothers and take offense. This person is trying to offend you, no matter what your sexuality. It just so happens "******" is a great way to cause offense.
SNIP
Take "bastard". Literally it means a child who's parents weren't married when they were conceived. This was bad back in the day when sex outside of marriage was considered a cardinal sin and the resulting bastards would be cursed. Nowadays, children outside of marriage are pretty commonplace, there's no longer the same social stigma attached to the concept. However "bastard" is still a general pejorative term and is still considered a pretty serious swear word. This is because people associate it now with offense rather than it's original meaning.
Same with "******", originally targeted towards gay people when homosexuality was not tolerated whatsoever, with the changing social climate and homosexuality becoming more and more accepted by society, it's losing it's impact as "gay = bad" and is instead being used because people associate it with offense.
We don't live in a society where gay people aren't marginalised, and I find it laughable that you seem to think we do. The word hasn't lost its homosexual meaning and all your assertions to the contrary are just wrong. I'm sorry, but it's not an arguable point. It's a question of facts and you got the facts dead wrong
I won't even get into the history of the word, or that for most queer people it can be extremely triggering for them because they routinely might have heard it as they were getting *physically assaulted*. No, I won't get into any detail about that, because the bare facts that you are defending the use of a *highly* insulting word to insult people by saying they are like me and being like me is bad should be enough to make you feel deep shame. And you consistent lack of said shame says mountains about your character as a human being. Jesus Christ. You have gone beyond insulting, and beyond insensitive. I'm now actually angry with you and think less of you as a person.
The slurs, the threats, and the utter lack of understanding or willingness to attempt it from people such as you. We don't want you to use that word. It is offensive. Your continued insistence that it is fine to use that word is one of the reasons why we've basically gone "Screw it, we'll have our own con."secretsantaone said:What exactly is it that makes videogames to alienating to gays?
I never said gays weren't marginalised, I said they were becoming less, thus meaning the word is gradually losing impact.
I also never said the word has stopped referring to homosexuals. I just said it can also be used as a general insult depending on the context. It's in a transitional period of gradually becoming the second meaning.
Really, you being offended doesn't mean that much to me because I know that I wasn't trying to be offensive. You can get offended about anything, it doesn't make you right.
If you can't deal with someone arguing an opposing viewpoint while backing it up with justifications and examples, without getting angry, then you're no better than an infant.