One Direction fanfic to be published as novel

Recommended Videos

pppppppppppppppppp

New member
Jun 23, 2011
1,519
0
0
I'm pretty sure this is where I set myself apart from most people here by saying that the One Direction members are incredibly cute, and for a preteen-marketed pop band, they really aren't that bad.

That said, the idea of teenagers making money off cheesy self-insert fanfics makes me just as sad as anyone.
 

Vault101

I'm in your mind fuzz
Sep 26, 2010
18,855
15
43
DanDeFool said:
That's a bit like saying McDonalds is a level of bad that shouldn't be acceptable in food services. There are certain kinds of "bad"that people still enjoy. And besides, there's also the possibility that they're not reading it for the same reason one reads Oscar Wilde or Shakespeare.
..I'm not talking about bad on a subjective level

people may enjoy it..sure and thats fine I guess

but the fact is the writing,,the actual words and how they are put together are NOT at a standard that should be published, let alone a bestseller
 

thesilentman

What this
Jun 14, 2012
4,512
0
0


OT- Thanks to the picture I don't need to say anything on how I feel about the fanfic. I'm just bugged that WHY AREN'T THEY PUBLISHING THE GOOD STUFF?! Are people that fucking greedy these days? I almost gave up reading due to all the shit my teachers are forcing down my throat in school, and now this? What the unholy fuck?

The sad part is that there is good fanfics out there, there are good original ideas out there, it's just that their drowned in the shit that populates a good chunk of the industry.

Now let me just relax and of the positive things that come of this, okay? Postivity, okay?

...
...

Nope got nothing positive for the industry. Where's that 'I don't want to live on this planet anymore meme'? Oh here.



Sorry for my language, mods, I'm having trouble writing well for my novel at this time to appease some people, so I'm really pissed on what's happening here with publishers. I'm prepared for the shocking possibility that the book may be good, but, I don't know anymore.
 

DanDeFool

Elite Member
Aug 19, 2009
1,891
0
41
Vault101 said:
DanDeFool said:
That's a bit like saying McDonalds is a level of bad that shouldn't be acceptable in food services. There are certain kinds of "bad"that people still enjoy. And besides, there's also the possibility that they're not reading it for the same reason one reads Oscar Wilde or Shakespeare.
..I'm not talking about bad on a subjective level

people may enjoy it..sure and thats fine I guess

but the fact is the writing,,the actual words and how they are put together are NOT at a standard that should be published, let alone a bestseller
Allow me to clarify.

A lot of people are comparing the work in question to pornography. I feel this is an apt comparison, partly because of my aforementioned point about why some people are interested in this stuff, but also because of how one might view its relation to criticism.

In other words, saying this book shouldn't be published because of its bad writing is like saying porn shouldn't be published because of bad acting. Yes, the writing may be terrible, but that's not really why they're reading, now is it?
 
Jun 16, 2010
1,153
0
0
It's funny. In the gaming world, women are marginalised and publishers do all they can to sell to men, using tough male heroes and shallow eye-candy women for maximum appeal. And there are shitstorms ever a-swirling around the issue.

On the other hand, in the writing world, men are marginalised and publishers do all they can to sell to women, using relatable female heroines and shallow eye-candy men. And nobody gives a crap.

I mean, people act like this is a new phenomenon with Twilight and 50 Shades selling like hot cakes. It isn't! Women have dominated the reader market for decades, and erotica novels have dominated the market for just as long (the creepier and more depraved the better).
It's reached the point where as a new, aspiring writer, you just won't sell a novel unless you've got at least two really dirty gratuitous shagging scenes.

And, as someone who takes writing seriously, it saddens me to see the great craft basically reduced to 'lady smut production'.
 

dtgenshiken7

New member
Aug 4, 2011
140
0
0
Oh sweet god no. I am not against people getting successful, and good on this random girl for making a publishable novel by 16, but WHY oh why was it a 1D fiction? At this point I'm writing from my scathing hatred of mainstream pop culture, but I still think this could be the worst thing to happen to books since 50 shades of grey and the twilight series. (as if you lot haven't covered that already). I am an aspiring fic writer, and I view it as incredibly unfair that just because she writes some 2-bit crap without any work done by herself short of thinking of a basic plot, it's 1D, so it hits the charts everywhere! Ugh, the stupidity of people burns me sometimes.

Captcha: Good Job. I think so too!
 

RJ 17

The Sound of Silence
Nov 27, 2011
8,687
0
0
Fappy said:
And this is why writers are some of the most depressing people on Earth.
Hey! I resent that!

But at the same time, I can't argue that. u.u
 

SuperSuperSuperGuy

New member
Jun 19, 2010
1,200
0
0
A 16-year-old girl is having a self-insert romance fanfiction about One Direction that she wrote published?!

I can't see this going anywhere good.