lacktheknack said:
I once tried to LP Mirror's Edge, but it just kept going wrong. I gave up after spending five hours on level 1, not including commentary.
I love exploding peoples' minds when I tell them that the best editing makes it look like there's been no editing.
Was the gameplay not turning out good, or were there technical problems. If it's the playing skill, I chalk that up to the Let's Play Curse. Basically you can be the best person at a game ever, but the moment you turn on that recording software, you suddenly play worse than a person who's never played a game before. For sudden bursts of good luck, see the elusive Let's Play Blessing.
As for commentary, for me I do live commentary because I hate doing post because I feel more rushed that I do when I'm doing live commentary. So in the current case for BioShock 2, I either have to a) rerecord again and lose out on using the footage in which I not only got the Grand Daddy Trophy, but the Master Protector one as well or b) do two hours of post commentary. T^T