When he reviews a game I have, or I get a game he's reviewed, I've never found him to be wrong. He and I might differ on how tolerable the aspect is but I've come to rely on his reviews - and I do consider them reviews, because they tell me in advance what to expect of the game, I don't know why some people don't consider them reviews, but then I don't know why some people consider marmite to be acceptable as food either - because I seem to have the same taste in games and what makes them enjoyable or not as his reviewing persona, just with greater emphasis on RPGs. Knowing in advance if something is going to irritate me into rage-quitting is very useful.