Let's see here... I went with amazing!, although that's not exactly true. It was better than good for quite a few reasons, but I don't think I'd ever call it amazing. Better then college? In some ways, yes. I didn't have to do as much, classes were easier to pull off without studying (or thinking about them at all really), and the band was significantly more fun. I'm sure that last one would have changed if we weren't very good, or if our football team in college was better, but as a rule getting high places - 1st 2nd or 3rd nearly every time - in marching band competitions was quite enjoyable, especially with a group of people that were fun to hang around with and a teacher who knew enough to be a good instructor but was at time completely oblivious (I've got some fun stories about that).
I had friends, but in the band and outside of it, I didn't do drugs, only drank a couple times and never seriously, I had a girlfriend for three of the four years, and I've had more than one girl I know come up to me and say that they had the biggest crush on me during that time. The school itself could have been better; some teachers I had were pretty good, one or two were amazing, and the rest could go screw themselves for all I cared. But dealing with that sort of shit has always been something that you have to go through. I did so by subtly screwing with them in every way possible. Oh, I had the occasional teacher who would give me F's and D's on big papers because they didn't like my style of writing or didn't like my argument, but the few who actually encouraged that sort of thinking were the ones I listened to.
The kids who I was never friends with could be jerks at times, of course, but I went through my fair share of that during middle school - middle school sucked, by the way - and my first few years in Scouts, and I quickly learned that having a thick skin and the ability to throw a glance someone's way that will tell them that under no uncertain terms if they continue what they're doing they're likely to end up with a bloody nose at best are two extraordinarily handy abilities to have. I got in a couple fights, but nothing serious and there were only a couple times that I came out with a bigger enemy than I went in to it with. Hell, I didn't even win all of them, but when you're able to stand up to a 6'3" tall, 200lb football player and match him punch for punch you tend to come out of it looking pretty good (we became friends pretty quickly afterwards. He went in to the Marine Corps, I became a writer).
Luckily for me these fights tended to happen off of school grounds and without any faculty knowing, otherwise my experience would have been quite a bit more interesting. I'll maintain that sometimes all a kid needs to straighten up is a good, non-serious ass kicking though, just so he'll realize there is someone out there that's bigger than him, and they're willing to let him know.
Erm... I didn't fit in with any particular social clique, but I managed to hang out with nearly all of them, and I think that helped out a lot in the end. I was myself, and I was confident about being myself, and I think because of that the people I spent time with didn't really care if I was their typical 'friend' or not.