Honestly, Yahtzee was the hook for me, if it wasn't for the offer of watching fresh episodes of Zero Punctuation, I wouldn't be assed to sign up and subscribe to Escapist, but in all honesty, I'd still stay because Jim Sterling's here, Thank God for Jim.
I can't say much for the rest, bar how SmoshGames shouldn't be here due to how retarded it's last top 5 was and how its credibility is reduced to nothing for me, MovieBob is great except he usually ends up overrating something that's not really good at all(GI Joe, anyone?), It's true he gets it 90% of the time, and that's great, but unlike Half in the Bag, wherein Jay and Mike are there to act as a check on each other if either one of them ends up recommending something that might be bad(Just like how Mike recommended Ghost Rider 2 at one point).
So yeah, tl;dr Jim Sterling's still here, so I'd still stay.