Sas: Yay because I see it fairly often, and it's a pretty damn good GIF,
Neon: Yay because it's extremely well known and entertaining,
Vaude: Half-Yay because her current The Shining one is a little boring, her one of the-person-who-I-can't-remember-who-it-is in the white dress with a little bit of blood on her has stuck with me,
Furb: Yay, because it's notorious 'round these parts,
BT: Yay because it is quite attention grabbing,
Julian: Nay, because I hvaen't seen it all too much,
Spork:Nay, because it isn't too interesting to me it's just kind of boring,
Pimpy: Yay, because like Furb, it's notorious here, and it also has grbbing colours,
PR's Rocky horror: Yay because I do still remember Tim Curry smiling at me.
PR's Fractal: Yay, because of the movement and colours
PR's Smiledog.jpg: Yay because it's bright and the teeth are interesting and stick in your mind.
Sleek's bear: Yay, because I remember it even now, after several weeks of him not having it.
Miracle of Sound: Nay, because it never really stuck in my head, it was just another transformers avatar.
Worgen: Yay, but I only really remember it vividly because people praise it so much.
Insanum: Yay, because of the smile and the mug with writing on.
Slouch: Nay, because I can't remember what it is, though I'll probably remember when I see him.
Douk: Yay, beccause it's bright and he drew it himself.
Onyx: Yay, because of the colours and th-ALL GLORY TO THE HYPNO-TOAD!!!