Scary? I'm with the AVP2 Marine camp .... Nerve-wracking, but you get used to it rather quickly.
Creepy? Silent Hill 2 freaked me out a couple of times, 'specially Pyramid Head. I got used to the radio pretty quickly, although it was freaky as hell the first hours.
Disturbing? Actually, American McGee's Alice had me in a rather weird mood after playing extended periods; sort of darkly trippy and a bit out of whack. The dream sequences in Max Payne deserve a mention as well, I think.
Creepy? Silent Hill 2 freaked me out a couple of times, 'specially Pyramid Head. I got used to the radio pretty quickly, although it was freaky as hell the first hours.
Disturbing? Actually, American McGee's Alice had me in a rather weird mood after playing extended periods; sort of darkly trippy and a bit out of whack. The dream sequences in Max Payne deserve a mention as well, I think.