jawakiller said:
Revrant said:
I saw this pop up on a right wing forum, most of them tried to justify the nuclear bombs with "well THEY wouldn't surrender so they DESERVED it"
As if not surrendering in a war with America is such an affront that you deserve to be nuked.
Hell is wrong with people?
Huh? That makes so little sense; I'm shocked. Any country back in the 1940s would have gladly nuked their enemies if it meant less causalities for their side.
Here are the pros and cons of a nuke (and a land invasion too).
Launch amphibious assault on Japan. Huge causalities on both sides but Americans lose at least a million soldiers (no, thats a real number). End result: Hundreds of thousands of men die, billions of dollars spent and Americans ***** forever about how stupid that was.
Nuke? A couple of aircraft-carriers get within flying distance of Japan, send off a few planes and proceed to "nuke the bastards." End result: Japs loose tens of thousands of lives (some innocent) and surrenders. America throws a party because they didn't loose every young man it sent to the war.
Now which one sounds better? For the Americans? For the Japanese? Explain your answer.
Uhh, that's an extremely callous, malicious way to take it, that we lose nothing and they lose hundreds of thousands of innocent women and children(No, not "some", that's weasel wording), it created animosity towards the US that to this day survives, it continues to be a contentious political issue, and it was one of the most terrible acts of genocide committed.
Furthermore, we were going to keep nuking civilians, as in, until they were either all dead or surrendered, we intended to keep preparing bombs and dropping them, it would have totaled a significant portion of the country's civilian population.
How, might I ask, would that be different from the genocide the Nazis were committed to? The reason I so detest it is because we nearly walked a very dark path, the path of our enemies, it is easy to wipe out millions of innocent lives to win a war, it is
right to win with your soul intact.