if they can put music on a cd why cant we download your wife's brain into a computer?Caramel Frappe said:First of all, I laughed incredibly hard at your OP- was hilarious and brilliant all the same. Second, I am very impressed that you brought up the flaws of immortality instead of just asking about it anyhow. Alright, time for my answer.the spud said:Snip
OT: No, I don't want to be immortal. Why? Because, I wasn't made to be given immortality. What would I possibly do over a course of a thousand years and counting? Eventually I would get to good at everything with much practice, thus couldn't expose myself (or have to change my identity every now and then) because I never will age so people will pick up on that.
Couldn't imagine outliving everyone I love or get close to. That's sticken depressing. That means I can never live happily with one wife, and continuing to see my kids, grandchildren, and so forth die out. Let's not even get started on how many pets I will have that pass away, never seeming to have any (not even a turtle or tortoise that could outlive me) pets to be with me forever. Life would blow, including mental pain from every incident. What if I somehow get trapped somewhere or held hostage? I'd suffer for years for who knows how long. So many things can backfire on immortality, along with losing yourself... because immortality can corrupt you. I'll pass.
Smarter is very questionable. Human brains already perform optimally on almost all tasks. You would probably see better input and output systems, but also better technology to afford you the same abilities and more (and you have infinite time, so if someone else won't, YOU can invent it).the spud said:1. Evolution will turn you into a freak: Over thousands of years something better, stronger, faster, and smarter will likely develop from humans, leaving you left behind as a freak.
What are they going to do to you? You can barely feel pain, they can't threaten to kill you. The thing to do here is obvious: instead of telling no one, tell EVERYONE. Make them love you, become a celebrity. If you suddenly "disappear", everyone needs to react extremely negatively. Hell, use your immortality to become a super hero and win the hearts of the world.the spud said:2. Nobody can ever find out: If you've got immortality then everybody will want it. Governments, CEO's, the masses, you name it. And they don't care what they have to do to get it.
This might be more worrisome if we actually had any idea what "growing older mentally" actually meant. There are plenty of people who don't ever develop any sort of age-related dementia or mental illness despite old age. There are plenty of elderly people with great memory and capacity for learning. So it's only reasonable to assume that these things are not a result of aging, but a result of some other weakening that comes with age. Since you aren't affected by such things, it's very unlikely that age-related mental problems would ever be an issue.the spud said:3. You're still getting older (mentally): You will be forced to remember everything that happens over the course of infinity, which your brain just isn't built to do.
I completely fail to see why you would expect the sensation of time to change dramatically with extreme age. While it's true that there's an age difference in people reporting how long time periods seem in hindsight, I have never heard of any suggestion that on-line perception of time differs for different age groups.the spud said:4. Time speeds up till you're insane: As time flies by, your different friends, loves, and lives slowly fade from your memory, making 50 years seem relatively equal to a saturday night.
This is probably the most terrifying one. However, it's pretty likely that you could figure out a sort of neural suicide by setting up environmental stimuli such that it would effectively overwrite the information currently in your brain given enough time.the spud said:5. You will eventually get trapped there forever: Eventually, you will get trapped in a pile of rubble, or the rest of the human race gets wiped out, and you till be trapped there forever.
The point of that video pretty much skipped over me because i couldnt stop thinking of how much that guy sounded like snake from MGS.Womplord said:Well ordinarily I'd say no, but I don't know if I'd be able to resist a gummi bear...
But seriously, there's no way I could say yes to such a thing. My arguments are basically summed up by the cracked article, especially the last point. You would be stuck for billions of years inside some black hole. Eternal consciousness is basically the ultimate form of torture.
Watch this if you say yes. Imagine Grahams number representing a number of years, would you still say yes?