Figures/Statues > Artbook > In-Game Items > Soundtrack > Random Items thrown in (maps, keychains, etc.)
This is my scale. I love the statues and stuff like that, if only because I have a love of tangible stuff (I'm one of those people that pays a little extra for a cd over the digital itunes copy, and who will continue to buy games in disc form). However, I absolutely love artwork as well (I used to buy strategy guides back when they actually included a decent amount of art as well, and when they were useful). In game items lots of time become DLC later, so that's less important. Plus I can only use it when playing the game. The soundtrack really depends on the game but it really doesn't make me more likely to pick up the game since I don't know what the soundtrack is before I get the game.